The Necessity of Reparation for Historic Injustices
Fascinating read on Northern Australian trade routes pre Colonisation.
The more that is uncovered pre European invasion the more incredibly rich the culture is showing to have been.
Would be unreal to discover more about how this place worked before we came along and changed it forever.
Read on.....
"AUSTRALIA’S PRE-COLONIAL SEAFARING TRADE
Groundbreaking archaeological research has confirmed scientifically what Indigenous peoples already knew, that first Australians were making huge overseas voyages to trade in a vast international network at least three millennia earlier than previously thought.
The common perception is that Australia’s culture evolved like its flora and fauna, in profound isolation across a deep history until Europeans arrived.
The archaeological record now shows as far back as 3000 years ago or more people from mainland Australia were building ocean-going double outrigger canoes up to 20 metres long and loading them up with crew and valuable goods and sailing thousands of kilometres to trade in distant lands.
Walmbaar Aboriginal Corporation director Kenneth McLean, a Dingaal Traditional Owner of Jiigurru, or Lizard Island, 33 kilometres off the Queensland coast says the discovery of artefacts that demonstrate the far-flung trade links of people from Cape York may enable his people to share a story they already knew with world.
“Our elders passed knowledge down through generations for us, teaching us how the old people were living back in the day, way before Captain Cook ever came,” McLean says.
“Hopefully we can educate Australians and the people around the world on how old our country is, and how old the international trade is.”
It’s commonly known that Makassan traders from the island of Sulawesi, in modern day Indonesia, were sailing south to Australia several hundred years ago, in the 1700s. Up until 1907 they traded iron and other goods with the locals of Arnhem Land and the Kimberleys in exchange for trepang, also known as sea cucumbers, and sold them into China.
Despite the cultural heritage of traditional owners along the coastline of Cape York, it is not well known that Aboriginal people had been sailing across the Coral Sea for thousands of years to trade.
About 3500 years ago the Lapita people, who colonised the western Pacific, came down from northern Vietnam or southern China or Taiwan and moved south to the Bismark Archipelago north of New Guinea and migrated eastwards to the Solomon Islands, Fiji, New Caledonia and Vanuatu.
Archaeologist Sean Ulm is the deputy director at the Australian Research Council Centre of Excellence for Australian Biodiversity and Heritage. He says the distinctive pottery of the Lapita is an archaeological calling card of their migration across Oceania.
It was accepted knowledge that Lapita migration from its starting place in the northern hemisphere only ever moved eastwards across the Bismark Archipelago to the northern New Guinea coast and then radiated across the Pacific.
Experts had uncovered no evidence that these seafaring people sailed west along the southern New Guinea coastline, until 2008 when a team of archaeologists started digging at a site in Caution Bay around 30 kilometres west of Port Moresby, ahead of a planned gas plant development.
Professor Ulm says he and a team of archaeologists “almost immediately” found Lapita pottery that was radiocarbon dated to 2800 years old.
“The team published that work for the first time in 2011 and it was met in the academic community with a lot of critique that it couldn’t possibly be Lapita, because Lapita people didn’t go westward along the southern New Guinea coast, they only went east (into the Pacific),” Ulm says.
“But, you know, here we are 10 years later and none of those critics disagree with us now. So it was a huge paradigm shift in the way people thought about the colonisation of the huge part of the planet and opened the door to suggest, if these people were in southern New Guinea 3000 years ago, where else could they be? They have watercraft, technology and seagoing technology.”
Anthropological archaeologist Ian McNiven also works with the Centre of Excellence for Australian Biodiversity and Heritage. He says archaeologists also started finding pottery in Torres Strait around 20 years ago, but there was “no historical or ethnographic or oral history of pottery production by Torres Strait Islanders”.
They started working with communities on excavations and found pottery for the first time. It was buried one metre under the ground, relatively deep in archaeological terms. The shards of pottery were discovered on Lizard Island by Ulm and McNiven in 2017.
“Everybody’s was saying ‘hey, that’s very different’. I’m saying bloody oath that’s different! That was unexpected,” McNiven says.
He says it appears pottery was traded into Torres Strait from New Guinea 3000 years ago, and some was produced locally. Finding a connection between the Lapita and Torres Strait, once they were known to have moved westwards across New Guinea, was not entirely unexpected, he says. But what came next on Lizard Island was a bolt from the blue.
“What was unexpected is finding similar pottery, of similar age on Lizard Island. It is 600 kilometres down the Queensland coast and that makes you say hang on, this is a serious game changer,” Professor McNiven says.
It was a seminal moment.
“You can literally hold a piece of pottery when we’re doing excavations on Lizard Island and pull it out from a metre underground, a piece the size of your thumbnail, and you say: everything changes after this,” McNiven says. “A little tiny piece like that changes the way we view the history of our continent and its interactions in the past, the Indigenous peoples with the outside world.
“Now we know Aboriginal peoples of North Queensland have these ancient connections going up through Torres Strait and into New Guinea and the pottery is telling us that it’s the calling card of people who are interacting over literally thousands of kilometres.”
McNiven, based at Monash University, says the evidence suggested it was not just the goods, but the knowledge of pottery making that had been passed on to people in Queensland.
“That Lizard Island pottery looks like it was made locally,” he says. “All the minerals in the pottery are essentially what you get around Lizard Island and that part of Cape York.”
Professor Ulm, of James Cook University, explained the pottery shards are smoking gun evidence that overturn the idea of Australia’s ancient isolation.
“There’s long been arguments that after people colonised Australia, somehow they lost that watercraft navigation technology, but we simply don’t know that because watercraft made out of organic materials don’t survive in the archaeological record,” he says.
“So these pottery finds, for example that we have on Lizard Island or in Torres Strait, show us that people are voyaging. Even though we don’t have the watercraft, it’s indirect evidence that people were making these voyages and we can trace how this knowledge or the objects themselves are moving.”
The historical evidence of trade across communities in the Coral Sea is extensive. These recent finds along with artefacts collected by 18th and 19th Century European voyagers shows a complex trading web across the region where goods particular to one location - including bamboo smoking pipes, canoes, spears and necklaces, as well as language and cultural practices - were passed back and forth across a long network. This has given rise to the concept of the Coral Sea Cultural Interaction Sphere.
Piecing together what was traded and by whom shows it involved hundreds of clans and dozens of language groups.
The groundbreaking pottery archaeology and evidence of ancient trading networks is showcased in a new exhibition, developed in partnership with the Walmbaar Aboriginal Corporation and Hope Vale Congress Aboriginal Corporation. Connections across the Coral Sea is at the Museum of Tropical Queensland in Townsville. It will move to Brisbane in June.
Professor Ulm says evidence for two-way trade, from New Guinea to Australia and vice-versa, overturned false stereotypes that had prevailed in historical assumptions about Aboriginal peoples.
“There was a prevailing view throughout the 19th and early 20th Century that any traded goods came south from New Guinea, but nothing went north,” Professor Ulm says.
“This was feeding into a racist construct that Aboriginal cultures are somehow simplistic and New Guinea and Melanesian cultures are somehow advanced were of course objects would only come south.
“But even in the 19th century, in the early 20th century, when writers began writing that, it wasn’t supported by the evidence then.
“We know that the Gulf of Carpentaria was linked to Adelaide, and Broome was linked to Alice Springs. But if you know what you’re doing you can cover a lot bigger distances in a boat than you can walking, carrying all your goods with you.”
Professor McNiven says Western science and Australia are “catching up with what Indigenous communities have known for a very long time”.
Australia was seen to be the only continent on the planet that didn’t have a pottery tradition, and that sort of played into all sorts of colonial representations of Indigenous people as being primitive or backward,” he says.
He says even though there were historical records of Australia’s international trading links preceding European settlement, it wasn’t studied systematically until the 1970s.
“Matthew Flinders was cruising around Australia in 1802 and comes into Arnhem Land and sees a whole fleet of Makassan vessels and goes ‘Excuse me, what’s going on here?’, I thought the British were the ones making the outside connections. But groups like the Yolngu Aboriginal community were going, come on, keep up. We’ve been doing this for hundreds of years mate.”
- by Mike Foley Sydney Morning Herald / The Age"
^^^ good read SR , so much history that we don’t know about . It would be interesting to read some of Chinese history earliest interactions .
Great call @supa. I'm sure there'd be early recordings somewhere from way back in Chinese history. All these threads are slowly piecing together. It's unreal watching the history slowly unfold to help paint a picture beyond the frivolity of the last 200 years.
Australia is more racist than even i gave it credit for. And i really thought it was racist already.
Shiver me timber.
The trading of Trepang is a whole other story.
It was going on for centuries, Indonesian seafarers making their way to Australia, purchasing and trading sea cucumber.
Routes into and out of Australia were established at a time way earlier than first thought by European settlers.
Our Aborigines were way ahead of time of so called ‘developed’ countries to our west.
It shames me to still think of how ignorant, arrogant and dismissive our own and other countries have been towards the longest continual culture of a human population on earth.
How about, just for once, we champion these people for what they really are, incredible resilient achievers.
Sean Ulm is a close colleague of my ex wife, I’ve met him on several occasions, wonderful guy. AW
Okay SR we have been agreeing too much of late, and we need a break from that USA thread.
IMHO it seems like a bit of a straw clutching article.
I dont see any evidence whatsoever in that article for the intro claim.
"that first Australians were making huge overseas voyages"
There is evidence Indonesians/Makasar people came here and traded for sea cucumber, there is even cave paintings of their boats.
But If FNP had that same open ocean sea going ability and were doing the same thing, they would have highly likely recorded what they had seen elsewhere when they returned and brought back ideas they had seen that we would see groups in say the north area take on different ideas with clear influence from the places they visited, they also would likely have brought back seeds of plants useful which would result in seeing non native plants in the areas that these boats departed from.
We would see obvious influence's from the people of closest areas of Sumba, Rote, East Timor, likely through adoption or influence of their designs and motifs in cave art etc
And the idea there is no boats because they are made of wood is silly, when white fella come they would have recorded seeing these large sea going boats, " ocean-going double outrigger canoes up to 20 metres long" (with sails) once they started going elsewhere they wouldn't stop they would continue and expand on the journeys and boats.
No doubt FNP in the far Cape York area had interaction with Torres's straight and PNG people, the distance between island's there isn't great, large canoes that FNP had could easily do those distances even paddling (you should see the distances between islands they do in tiny canoes in Indo) and you would expect in most cases islands could be seen in the distance to travel too, thats very realistic, but traveling hundreds of Kilometres towards nothing but open blue water making it and returning is not, even if they made the journey one way returning is another thing.
BTW. There could have been belief's/stories/mythology of what was out there that prevented any motivation to see and anyone that tried and didn't return would confirm these beliefs.
A quick google shows Lapita pottery is found in PNG as is other pottery, so obviously it came here the same way it got there or came here via PNG.
It's surprising that FNP really never had pottery, but then again being nomadic you dont want to be carting around heavy clay pots and there wasn't any domesticated animal's to help move these items.
southernraw wrote:Fascinating read on Northern Australian trade routes pre Colonisation.
The more that is uncovered pre European invasion the more incredibly rich the culture is showing to have been.
Would be unreal to discover more about how this place worked before we came along and changed it forever.
Read on.....
"AUSTRALIA’S PRE-COLONIAL SEAFARING TRADE
Groundbreaking archaeological research has confirmed scientifically what Indigenous peoples already knew, that first Australians were making huge overseas voyages to trade in a vast international network at least three millennia earlier than previously thought.
The common perception is that Australia’s culture evolved like its flora and fauna, in profound isolation across a deep history until Europeans arrived.
The archaeological record now shows as far back as 3000 years ago or more people from mainland Australia were building ocean-going double outrigger canoes up to 20 metres long and loading them up with crew and valuable goods and sailing thousands of kilometres to trade in distant lands.
Walmbaar Aboriginal Corporation director Kenneth McLean, a Dingaal Traditional Owner of Jiigurru, or Lizard Island, 33 kilometres off the Queensland coast says the discovery of artefacts that demonstrate the far-flung trade links of people from Cape York may enable his people to share a story they already knew with world.
“Our elders passed knowledge down through generations for us, teaching us how the old people were living back in the day, way before Captain Cook ever came,” McLean says.
“Hopefully we can educate Australians and the people around the world on how old our country is, and how old the international trade is.”
It’s commonly known that Makassan traders from the island of Sulawesi, in modern day Indonesia, were sailing south to Australia several hundred years ago, in the 1700s. Up until 1907 they traded iron and other goods with the locals of Arnhem Land and the Kimberleys in exchange for trepang, also known as sea cucumbers, and sold them into China.
Despite the cultural heritage of traditional owners along the coastline of Cape York, it is not well known that Aboriginal people had been sailing across the Coral Sea for thousands of years to trade.
About 3500 years ago the Lapita people, who colonised the western Pacific, came down from northern Vietnam or southern China or Taiwan and moved south to the Bismark Archipelago north of New Guinea and migrated eastwards to the Solomon Islands, Fiji, New Caledonia and Vanuatu.
Archaeologist Sean Ulm is the deputy director at the Australian Research Council Centre of Excellence for Australian Biodiversity and Heritage. He says the distinctive pottery of the Lapita is an archaeological calling card of their migration across Oceania.
It was accepted knowledge that Lapita migration from its starting place in the northern hemisphere only ever moved eastwards across the Bismark Archipelago to the northern New Guinea coast and then radiated across the Pacific.
Experts had uncovered no evidence that these seafaring people sailed west along the southern New Guinea coastline, until 2008 when a team of archaeologists started digging at a site in Caution Bay around 30 kilometres west of Port Moresby, ahead of a planned gas plant development.
Professor Ulm says he and a team of archaeologists “almost immediately” found Lapita pottery that was radiocarbon dated to 2800 years old.
“The team published that work for the first time in 2011 and it was met in the academic community with a lot of critique that it couldn’t possibly be Lapita, because Lapita people didn’t go westward along the southern New Guinea coast, they only went east (into the Pacific),” Ulm says.
“But, you know, here we are 10 years later and none of those critics disagree with us now. So it was a huge paradigm shift in the way people thought about the colonisation of the huge part of the planet and opened the door to suggest, if these people were in southern New Guinea 3000 years ago, where else could they be? They have watercraft, technology and seagoing technology.”
Anthropological archaeologist Ian McNiven also works with the Centre of Excellence for Australian Biodiversity and Heritage. He says archaeologists also started finding pottery in Torres Strait around 20 years ago, but there was “no historical or ethnographic or oral history of pottery production by Torres Strait Islanders”.
They started working with communities on excavations and found pottery for the first time. It was buried one metre under the ground, relatively deep in archaeological terms. The shards of pottery were discovered on Lizard Island by Ulm and McNiven in 2017.
“Everybody’s was saying ‘hey, that’s very different’. I’m saying bloody oath that’s different! That was unexpected,” McNiven says.
He says it appears pottery was traded into Torres Strait from New Guinea 3000 years ago, and some was produced locally. Finding a connection between the Lapita and Torres Strait, once they were known to have moved westwards across New Guinea, was not entirely unexpected, he says. But what came next on Lizard Island was a bolt from the blue.
“What was unexpected is finding similar pottery, of similar age on Lizard Island. It is 600 kilometres down the Queensland coast and that makes you say hang on, this is a serious game changer,” Professor McNiven says.
It was a seminal moment.
“You can literally hold a piece of pottery when we’re doing excavations on Lizard Island and pull it out from a metre underground, a piece the size of your thumbnail, and you say: everything changes after this,” McNiven says. “A little tiny piece like that changes the way we view the history of our continent and its interactions in the past, the Indigenous peoples with the outside world.
“Now we know Aboriginal peoples of North Queensland have these ancient connections going up through Torres Strait and into New Guinea and the pottery is telling us that it’s the calling card of people who are interacting over literally thousands of kilometres.”
McNiven, based at Monash University, says the evidence suggested it was not just the goods, but the knowledge of pottery making that had been passed on to people in Queensland.
“That Lizard Island pottery looks like it was made locally,” he says. “All the minerals in the pottery are essentially what you get around Lizard Island and that part of Cape York.”
Professor Ulm, of James Cook University, explained the pottery shards are smoking gun evidence that overturn the idea of Australia’s ancient isolation.
“There’s long been arguments that after people colonised Australia, somehow they lost that watercraft navigation technology, but we simply don’t know that because watercraft made out of organic materials don’t survive in the archaeological record,” he says.
“So these pottery finds, for example that we have on Lizard Island or in Torres Strait, show us that people are voyaging. Even though we don’t have the watercraft, it’s indirect evidence that people were making these voyages and we can trace how this knowledge or the objects themselves are moving.”
The historical evidence of trade across communities in the Coral Sea is extensive. These recent finds along with artefacts collected by 18th and 19th Century European voyagers shows a complex trading web across the region where goods particular to one location - including bamboo smoking pipes, canoes, spears and necklaces, as well as language and cultural practices - were passed back and forth across a long network. This has given rise to the concept of the Coral Sea Cultural Interaction Sphere.
Piecing together what was traded and by whom shows it involved hundreds of clans and dozens of language groups.
The groundbreaking pottery archaeology and evidence of ancient trading networks is showcased in a new exhibition, developed in partnership with the Walmbaar Aboriginal Corporation and Hope Vale Congress Aboriginal Corporation. Connections across the Coral Sea is at the Museum of Tropical Queensland in Townsville. It will move to Brisbane in June.
Professor Ulm says evidence for two-way trade, from New Guinea to Australia and vice-versa, overturned false stereotypes that had prevailed in historical assumptions about Aboriginal peoples.
“There was a prevailing view throughout the 19th and early 20th Century that any traded goods came south from New Guinea, but nothing went north,” Professor Ulm says.
“This was feeding into a racist construct that Aboriginal cultures are somehow simplistic and New Guinea and Melanesian cultures are somehow advanced were of course objects would only come south.
“But even in the 19th century, in the early 20th century, when writers began writing that, it wasn’t supported by the evidence then.
“We know that the Gulf of Carpentaria was linked to Adelaide, and Broome was linked to Alice Springs. But if you know what you’re doing you can cover a lot bigger distances in a boat than you can walking, carrying all your goods with you.”
Professor McNiven says Western science and Australia are “catching up with what Indigenous communities have known for a very long time”.
Australia was seen to be the only continent on the planet that didn’t have a pottery tradition, and that sort of played into all sorts of colonial representations of Indigenous people as being primitive or backward,” he says.
He says even though there were historical records of Australia’s international trading links preceding European settlement, it wasn’t studied systematically until the 1970s.
“Matthew Flinders was cruising around Australia in 1802 and comes into Arnhem Land and sees a whole fleet of Makassan vessels and goes ‘Excuse me, what’s going on here?’, I thought the British were the ones making the outside connections. But groups like the Yolngu Aboriginal community were going, come on, keep up. We’ve been doing this for hundreds of years mate.”
- by Mike Foley Sydney Morning Herald / The Age"
Fascinating, thanks for posting that.
indo-dreaming wrote:Okay SR we have been agreeing too much of late, and we need a break from that USA thread.
IMHO it seems like a bit of a straw clutching article.
I dont see any evidence whatsoever in that article for the intro claim.
"that first Australians were making huge overseas voyages"
There is evidence Indonesians/Makasar people came here and traded for sea cucumber, there is even cave paintings of their boats.
But If FNP had that same open ocean sea going ability and were doing the same thing, they would have highly likely recorded what they had seen elsewhere when they returned and brought back ideas they had seen that we would see groups in say the north area take on different ideas with clear influence from the places they visited, they also would likely have brought back seeds of plants useful which would result in seeing non native plants in the areas that these boats departed from.
We would see obvious influence's from the people of closest areas of Sumba, Rote, East Timor, likely through adoption or influence of their designs and motifs in cave art etc
And the idea there is no boats because they are made of wood is silly, when white fella come they would have recorded seeing these large sea going boats, " ocean-going double outrigger canoes up to 20 metres long" (with sails) once they started going elsewhere they wouldn't stop they would continue and expand on the journeys and boats.
No doubt FNP in the far Cape York area had interaction with Torres's straight and PNG people, the distance between island's there isn't great, large canoes that FNP had could easily do those distances even paddling (you should see the distances between islands they do in tiny canoes in Indo) and you would expect in most cases islands could be seen in the distance to travel too, thats very realistic, but traveling hundreds of Kilometres towards nothing but open blue water making it and returning is not, even if they made the journey one way returning is another thing.
BTW. There could have been belief's/stories/mythology of what was out there that prevented any motivation to see and anyone that tried and didn't return would confirm these beliefs.
A quick google shows Lapita pottery is found in PNG as is other pottery, so obviously it came here the same way it got there or came here via PNG.
It's surprising that FNP really never had pottery, but then again being nomadic you dont want to be carting around heavy clay pots and there wasn't any domesticated animal's to help move these items.
Indo, agreed, much prefer this trench warfare than the niceties with you.
Having said that, i read your post, and i can't confirm nor deny anything you post, i simply don't know.
I do know this is an extremely remote part of Australia. Can't imagine cook and his band of merry followers got around these parts too much in early settlement.
Is there recorded evidence? Maybe there was. Maybe it hasn't been found. Maybe it deteriorated. Story? don't know. Good points you raise but it seems alot more well researched than both you and i have done, but i'll look into it some more over the next few weeks/months and try to learn more. Not trying to disprove what you say. If it is true, i think it's fascinating, and based on the story and discussion from AW above etc, it seems to hold some legitimate truths. But yeah, fair to point out a lack of evidence, because, like i said, i don't know and i didn't actually fact check it so my bad i guess.
Will get back to this at some point.
Either way it is an interesting topic.
It would be surprising if there wasn't more Indonesian contact with FNP than they think.
Madagacar is pretty far from Indonesia yet there is evidence that they sailed there over 1,000 years ago there is even DNA links.
It would interesting to see or know what the DNA studies say with FNP & Indonesian contact is there FNP DNA found in areas of Indonesia population or Indonesian DNA found in some FNP communities?
"30 Indonesian Women (Accidentally) Founded Madagascar"
"Previous genetic research showed that, surprisingly, instead of coming from Africa, the people living on the island off the east coast of Africa seem to have come from Indonesia, another island nation a quarter of the world, or some 3,500 miles (about 5,600 kilometers), away."
https://www.livescience.com/19188-indonesian-women-founded-madagascar.html
BTW. this is a real cool read, quite in depth.
"Dreamtime voyagers: Aboriginal Australians in early modern Makassar"
https://mikedashhistory.com/2016/10/31/dreamtime-voyagers-australian-abo...
Agree...thanx southernraw & crew...much to explore in this regard...
truebluebasher WEDNESDAY, 14 JUN 2023
Early navigators judged population by lack of resource tided upon shorelines...as in Coconuts!
First Nation studied Seed Pods upon the shore & crocodiles bodysurf tides between continents.
https://www.nationalgeographic.com/animals/article/100607-science-animal...
The Aboriginal Tidal Raft was born to surf intercontinental tides off the moon...island hopping to China.
Check this story...Debris from Indo / Taiwan / Thailand / China washes up on Little Bondi NT.
Meaning...if any surf these tidal waves ya gotta surf ashore or wrestle crocodiles.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-07-23/plastic-waste-growing-on-arnhem-l...
Now check this similar Story...Balinese say beach waste is tided from Java. ( Also notice it being another wave beach )
So we can easily assume that Island hoppers must learn to surf to freely exit each paylode ashore of tidal front.
We see big surf / tides brought these shown payloads...which opens up possibility of Rafting larger Pontoons of goods!
We also know that a shoreline wipeout would render the trade mission a failure & or death, even by tribe.
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2021/2/5/balis-beaches-blighted-by-rubbis...
Ya see...just sit on any of these rafts of timber & ya can island hop with purpose by the tides!
Even Kooks would know if you were surfing alongside a Croc that food is abundant exiting tided exotic shore break.
With using our surf knowledge we can easily trace back surf history with Aboriginal -Asian Trade by default.
Reckon we can safely lock it in without stickers! It's a no brainer even without using our brains...
It's gonna happen every single time a wave breaks upon same shore or tides to up river surf trade hub.
Ya Island hopping surf raft pretty much invented itself... Simply 'timetable the moon' for Mass Migration!
Many exotic Chinese / Indian narcotic plants & utensils align original Pituri trade routes well into Oz.
Woven Palm cups to Goldie to SA Large Shells holding Hot water...just order what ya want & sell yer Brew/Herbs
Brewed / Herbs / Vice / Pearls were always the lightest valuable Raft Cargo...no time era can alter that science!
Still today these Pacific Islands hub Global Vice of whatever peddling raft...prisons are overcrowded.
Women were not permitted on route unless they were being traded...
Mobs ruled of Village Storage Hubs designed & built to store Vice along the Route...(Notably Vice)
Now ya know why they needed Mobs to defend or protect stash & did form Trade Pacts just as today!
Routes are said to extend to 5,000 years trading...much & many maps to Alice Springs & on...
Much of the Trade is governed by seasonality of Rains / Droughts as to Drug Potency/Worth
...hence the need for Storage Hubs run by Ruthless Mob Cartels just as today!
Tidal Bore Trade Surfing Technique/s
As tidal wave approaches river mouth it rises, speeds & narrows resulting in SUP action to hold wave.
Pause : At this point...( Note Aborigines have slip raft )
It is feasible to split from Parent Raft to smaller single surf craft with trailer to keep with the wave...
This craft might better resemble surf craft as we know it...
The jettisoned lesser precious > bulk raft stock can be detoured to inlet or brought up river with time as a pontoon.
We call this birling...one hits their oar to split raft into 2/3/4 loads & surfs desired payload with the Wave.
This is a highly feasible natural skillful surf action to keep surfing the wave...(Check links)
Any wipeout & yer croc food...gotta walk the raft real good to surf the wave up river.
Top End Aborigines traded afar by surfing tides timetabled by the Moon .
tbb further shares Ancient Tidal Bore Surfing Trade
https://www.swellnet.com/news/the-depth-test/2019/08/08/review-children-...
3rd March 2023 tbb intros / explains the skill of Intercontinental Tidal Surfing
https://www.swellnet.com/news/reels/2023/02/27/watch-the-physics-noseriding
Also share / explore 1100's Global Surf Industry Trade Routes to Surf Town Munich.
https://www.swellnet.com/comment/904859
Crew can relive that Surf Trade era with Tourist Style River Surfing Tours as Japan.
Gold Coast were planning a Chinese Song Era River Surfing Theme Park at Nerang Train Station.
Closely resembled original 1829 Tweed / Goldie Convict Surfcraft > export Trade to UK.
( 1100's Early Global Surf Empire )
Not saying the First or 2nd Wave See Greece - Mid East > Maybe 1100's as the 3rd wave?
But well established long before final newest Wave of Modern recreational Polynesian Surfing!
What's interesting is earliest intercontinental Trade Ports were serviced by Tidal Craft
Then came the Trade Wind "Polynesians accessing deeper less tidal Central Island Bays.
Followed by Big States with Billowing Sail Craft trading into Deeper Southern & Northern Ports.
With opening of Continental Canals this gauges central Ports servicing Great Circle Equatorial Current.
Estuarine ports are mass dredged to Panama's Gauge & now double the effect of Man-made climate Tides.
There are examples of Hybrid Wind assisted Craft that may shift trade routes & Ports once again...
For sure...follow these original Tidal Surfers Trade Routes & Ports to uncover earlier Surf Nations!
Here's an example of an Earlier Surf Route or supposed earlier epic Surf Craft voyage.
Tasmanian Ocean Reed Canoes
https://www.nma.gov.au/__data/assets/image/0004/556456/MA60664799-Schout...
To South America Chilean Reed Canoes (Exact Same thing...but how?)
https://i.pinimg.com/736x/2b/2c/37/2b2c37dbebbcfe737c85dad178644f84--lak...
This was deemed the most likely Island hopping route...for Aboriginal voyage to South America.
Perfectly explains how early expert Oz surfcraft gets exported to South America...(Any other ideas?)
http://realhistoryww.com/world_history/ancient/Misc/Ancient_American_aff...
If crew wanna further explore where these Tassie > Chile Reed Canoes originated ...
tbb was curious as to why SA First Nation pioneered Reed Surfing culture.
It was recently revealed that first nation lived during the Inland sea period...
Crew can actually trace reed canoes / Floating Reed Mat Island chains to upper SA.
Where once a massive Thriving Surf Coast Culture existed > Now an inland sea > Desert.
southernraw wrote:indo-dreaming wrote:Okay SR we have been agreeing too much of late, and we need a break from that USA thread.
IMHO it seems like a bit of a straw clutching article.
I dont see any evidence whatsoever in that article for the intro claim.
"that first Australians were making huge overseas voyages"
There is evidence Indonesians/Makasar people came here and traded for sea cucumber, there is even cave paintings of their boats.
But If FNP had that same open ocean sea going ability and were doing the same thing, they would have highly likely recorded what they had seen elsewhere when they returned and brought back ideas they had seen that we would see groups in say the north area take on different ideas with clear influence from the places they visited, they also would likely have brought back seeds of plants useful which would result in seeing non native plants in the areas that these boats departed from.
We would see obvious influence's from the people of closest areas of Sumba, Rote, East Timor, likely through adoption or influence of their designs and motifs in cave art etc
And the idea there is no boats because they are made of wood is silly, when white fella come they would have recorded seeing these large sea going boats, " ocean-going double outrigger canoes up to 20 metres long" (with sails) once they started going elsewhere they wouldn't stop they would continue and expand on the journeys and boats.
No doubt FNP in the far Cape York area had interaction with Torres's straight and PNG people, the distance between island's there isn't great, large canoes that FNP had could easily do those distances even paddling (you should see the distances between islands they do in tiny canoes in Indo) and you would expect in most cases islands could be seen in the distance to travel too, thats very realistic, but traveling hundreds of Kilometres towards nothing but open blue water making it and returning is not, even if they made the journey one way returning is another thing.
BTW. There could have been belief's/stories/mythology of what was out there that prevented any motivation to see and anyone that tried and didn't return would confirm these beliefs.
A quick google shows Lapita pottery is found in PNG as is other pottery, so obviously it came here the same way it got there or came here via PNG.
It's surprising that FNP really never had pottery, but then again being nomadic you dont want to be carting around heavy clay pots and there wasn't any domesticated animal's to help move these items.
Indo, agreed, much prefer this trench warfare than the niceties with you.
Having said that, i read your post, and i can't confirm nor deny anything you post, i simply don't know.
I do know this is an extremely remote part of Australia. Can't imagine cook and his band of merry followers got around these parts too much in early settlement.
Is there recorded evidence? Maybe there was. Maybe it hasn't been found. Maybe it deteriorated. Story? don't know. Good points you raise but it seems alot more well researched than both you and i have done, but i'll look into it some more over the next few weeks/months and try to learn more. Not trying to disprove what you say. If it is true, i think it's fascinating, and based on the story and discussion from AW above etc, it seems to hold some legitimate truths. But yeah, fair to point out a lack of evidence, because, like i said, i don't know and i didn't actually fact check it so my bad i guess.
Will get back to this at some point.
Southernraw. Hi pal, hope you’re getting wet.
Many years ago I read an outstanding book written by Andrew McMillan.
‘An Intruder’s Guide to East Arnhem Land’
Well worth a read to understand the gamete of different visitors that reacted, traded , befriended, opposed and also ripped off aboriginal people.
The Trepang trade was enormous, a big economy in those times, sea faring vessels travelled in fleets at times, taking the sea cucumbers back to Indo. AW
An Intruder's Guide to East Arnhem Land : What Happened to Aborigines After Europeans Came to the Territory - Andrew McMillan
Wonderful part of thread on the ancient trade routes. They may yet find ships. Oldest found preserved so far are around 3500-4000 years old.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kon-Tiki_expedition
It can be done.
Unreal. Thanks for all the reading and links crew.
Much appreciated and look forward to checking them out.
southernraw wrote:Australia is more racist than even i gave it credit for. And i really thought it was racist already.
Shiver me timber.
Was that the beers talking last night or you honestly think that?
AlfredWallace wrote:southernraw wrote:indo-dreaming wrote:Okay SR we have been agreeing too much of late, and we need a break from that USA thread.
IMHO it seems like a bit of a straw clutching article.
I dont see any evidence whatsoever in that article for the intro claim.
"that first Australians were making huge overseas voyages"
There is evidence Indonesians/Makasar people came here and traded for sea cucumber, there is even cave paintings of their boats.
But If FNP had that same open ocean sea going ability and were doing the same thing, they would have highly likely recorded what they had seen elsewhere when they returned and brought back ideas they had seen that we would see groups in say the north area take on different ideas with clear influence from the places they visited, they also would likely have brought back seeds of plants useful which would result in seeing non native plants in the areas that these boats departed from.
We would see obvious influence's from the people of closest areas of Sumba, Rote, East Timor, likely through adoption or influence of their designs and motifs in cave art etc
And the idea there is no boats because they are made of wood is silly, when white fella come they would have recorded seeing these large sea going boats, " ocean-going double outrigger canoes up to 20 metres long" (with sails) once they started going elsewhere they wouldn't stop they would continue and expand on the journeys and boats.
No doubt FNP in the far Cape York area had interaction with Torres's straight and PNG people, the distance between island's there isn't great, large canoes that FNP had could easily do those distances even paddling (you should see the distances between islands they do in tiny canoes in Indo) and you would expect in most cases islands could be seen in the distance to travel too, thats very realistic, but traveling hundreds of Kilometres towards nothing but open blue water making it and returning is not, even if they made the journey one way returning is another thing.
BTW. There could have been belief's/stories/mythology of what was out there that prevented any motivation to see and anyone that tried and didn't return would confirm these beliefs.
A quick google shows Lapita pottery is found in PNG as is other pottery, so obviously it came here the same way it got there or came here via PNG.
It's surprising that FNP really never had pottery, but then again being nomadic you dont want to be carting around heavy clay pots and there wasn't any domesticated animal's to help move these items.
Indo, agreed, much prefer this trench warfare than the niceties with you.
Having said that, i read your post, and i can't confirm nor deny anything you post, i simply don't know.
I do know this is an extremely remote part of Australia. Can't imagine cook and his band of merry followers got around these parts too much in early settlement.
Is there recorded evidence? Maybe there was. Maybe it hasn't been found. Maybe it deteriorated. Story? don't know. Good points you raise but it seems alot more well researched than both you and i have done, but i'll look into it some more over the next few weeks/months and try to learn more. Not trying to disprove what you say. If it is true, i think it's fascinating, and based on the story and discussion from AW above etc, it seems to hold some legitimate truths. But yeah, fair to point out a lack of evidence, because, like i said, i don't know and i didn't actually fact check it so my bad i guess.
Will get back to this at some point.Southernraw. Hi pal, hope you’re getting wet.
Many years ago I read an outstanding book written by Andrew McMillan.
‘An Intruder’s Guide to East Arnhem Land’
Well worth a read to understand the gamete of different visitors that reacted, traded , befriended, opposed and also ripped off aboriginal people.
The Trepang trade was enormous, a big economy in those times, sea faring vessels travelled in fleets at times, taking the sea cucumbers back to Indo. AWAn Intruder's Guide to East Arnhem Land : What Happened to Aborigines After Europeans Came to the Territory - Andrew McMillan
Edit. Appalling grammar by yours truly, should read gamut, not gamete(a sex cell)
goofyfoot wrote:southernraw wrote:Australia is more racist than even i gave it credit for. And i really thought it was racist already.
Shiver me timber.Was that the beers talking last night or you honestly think that?
Hi Goofy. Nah the real deal. Ive been dealing w some really dumb racist shit lately....yesterday was a doozy. Was just venting. A long long way to go in this country when look at my friends and associates. Hope ur well mate.
southernraw wrote:goofyfoot wrote:southernraw wrote:Australia is more racist than even i gave it credit for. And i really thought it was racist already.
Shiver me timber.Was that the beers talking last night or you honestly think that?
Hi Goofy. Nah the real deal. Ive been dealing w some really dumb racist shit lately....yesterday was a doozy. Was just venting. A long long way to go in this country when look at my friends and associates. Hope ur well mate.
Fair enough sr, you’re speaking from first hand experience. That’s a shame you’re experiencing that.
@Southern,
Bit off the early traders topic but while we are loading you up with references.
.
Don't know if you are familiar with the story of James Morrill and his work "Sketch of a Residence Among the Aboriginals of Northern Queensland for Seventeen Years". (being a narrative of my life, shipwreck, landing, on the coast, residence among the Aboriginals, with an account of their manners and customs, and more of living; together with notices of many of the natural productions, and of the nature of the country) (1863).
https://townsville.spydus.com/tsvhistoryonline/C7012394059.pdf
If you've never read it I think you would find it a great read as I did when I discovered it.
It's regarded as one of Australia's most important national treasures. A seminal work.
Morrill was the only (ultimately) survivor of a shipwreck off Minerva Reef taken in half starved to death by the local Aboriginal tribes and lived with them for 17 years.
He didn't keep a diary, but wrote this account, three short chapters, with chapter 2 being the most interesting, sometimes funny, but ultimately sad when he finally makes contact with white settlers and leaves. It's an interesting perspective of the lives, thoughts and fears of FNP when first contact was happening, in the words of a man that was with them.
Chapter three he makes some more general remarks and observations, some fascinating, some that would probably upset a few today, but they are there and so was he, and that was how he saw things at the time. See what you think if you read it.
You can probably skip to page 4 chapter II to skip his early life if TL.
I was always aware of William Buckley and Pelletiere as Europeans who lived extensively with original traditional FNP but stumbled on Morrill's account by accident years ago and it made a big impression on me.
Hope you get a chance to have a read if you never have. I know you have a keen interest in these things.
keep on rockin'@Southern.
Hey @adam12, always so good and refreshing to hear from you! Shit yeah i hadnt heard of it but I'll check it out on your recommendation!!! 100%. Thanks so much!
Im also on the hunt for a copy of a book called "Some people want to Shoot Me" by Madeleine Dickie. An amazing writer with lived experience and a lovely human too. Ive heard its a cracking read based on real events.
Thanks legend and hope you're well
And also good onya @goofyfoot and cheers. Yeah just a bit of a flare up. Lets blame the planets again cos reading this thread today has been wholesome and fullfilling to read each and alls input. Theres alot of good humans out there so cheers to u all for restoring the faith.
adam12 wrote:@Southern,
Bit off the early traders topic but while we are loading you up with references.
.
Don't know if you are familiar with the story of James Morrill and his work "Sketch of a Residence Among the Aboriginals of Northern Queensland for Seventeen Years". (being a narrative of my life, shipwreck, landing, on the coast, residence among the Aboriginals, with an account of their manners and customs, and more of living; together with notices of many of the natural productions, and of the nature of the country) (1863).https://townsville.spydus.com/tsvhistoryonline/C7012394059.pdf
If you've never read it I think you would find it a great read as I did when I discovered it.
It's regarded as one of Australia's most important national treasures. A seminal work.
Morrill was the only (ultimately) survivor of a shipwreck off Minerva Reef taken in half starved to death by the local Aboriginal tribes and lived with them for 17 years.
He didn't keep a diary, but wrote this account, three short chapters, with chapter 2 being the most interesting, sometimes funny, but ultimately sad when he finally makes contact with white settlers and leaves. It's an interesting perspective of the lives, thoughts and fears of FNP when first contact was happening, in the words of a man that was with them.
Chapter three he makes some more general remarks and observations, some fascinating, some that would probably upset a few today, but they are there and so was he, and that was how he saw things at the time. See what you think if you read it.
You can probably skip to page 4 chapter II to skip his early life if TL.I was always aware of William Buckley and Pelletiere as Europeans who lived extensively with original traditional FNP but stumbled on Morrill's account by accident years ago and it made a big impression on me.
Hope you get a chance to have a read if you never have. I know you have a keen interest in these things.keep on rockin'@Southern.
Adam12 & Southernraw and the rest of us fine folks.
Out of interest, ‘The Life and Adventures of William Buckley’ by John Morgan.
A good read typically local to Geelong, Point Impossible and the Bellarine Peninsula in. Victoria.
In the 90’s I was the construction manager (voluntary) for Surfrider Foundation, loads of great undertakings, in particular the protection of sensitive sites at Point Impossible.
Long story short, another landscape mate of mine, his crew of guys coupled with my crew, worked there for 16 days in the month of June after successfully winning a tender application for works to construct the present stone steps down to the beach, alter the fencing and revegetation works.
We built the still intact good stone steps, some later iterations by others for more stone steps towards Thompson Creek are complete shit.
This car park area was occupied by Wada Wurrung people back in the day.
The restorative works were about protecting very sensitive sites ( I can’t reveal the details), changing the car parking area to what it is today because for decades us surfers had been parking on a huge midden.
Fish/eel traps were also present etc.
Myself in particular felt a real ‘sense of place’ whilst working, all the while knowing the history of earlier occupation and that William Buckley lived within that group of people for quite sometime, even learning their language.
I won’t spoil the book, it’s sad, brutal at times and also joyful.
After reading the book, you’ll definitely have a different thought process going through your mind when you next visit.
Tracks Magazine made a surprise visit one day whilst working, they titled their story ‘One Step at A Time’, very pertinent to the locations past and to the work we we were doing. Comically, they stated, it looked like more surfing was being undertaken than stonework on some days.
We were lucky, had a couple of good swells whilst there. AW
Hi AW. Thats epic, and thanks for sharing that.
Like many on Swellnet, i feel i have a pretty strong energetic connection to that part of the world, and really welcome learning more about times of yore, and what the place really is about. There's some powerful energy in that part of the world, particlarly the Bells/Jarrasite all the way to Addis, and also the Otway to Peterborough zone. Very powerful energy, not just in the ocean. Makes you wonder hey. Also a fair bit of energy around the Kardinia park region eh ;-)
Would hope to cross paths with the great AW and @a12 and many others here at some point in the future. Alot of shared stories and wisdom passed on no doubt.
I wish i had something of significance to add to the convo at this point, but not right now. Just wanna say cheers and loving these recommendations.
southernraw wrote:Hi AW. Thats epic, and thanks for sharing that.
Like many on Swellnet, i feel i have a pretty strong energetic connection to that part of the world, and really welcome learning more about times of yore, and what the place really is about. There's some powerful energy in that part of the world, particlarly the Bells/Jarrasite all the way to Addis, and also the Otway to Peterborough zone. Very powerful energy, not just in the ocean. Makes you wonder hey. Also a fair bit of energy around the Kardinia park region eh ;-)
Would hope to cross paths with the great AW and @a12 and many others here at some point in the future. Alot of shared stories and wisdom passed on no doubt.
I wish i had something of significance to add to the convo at this point, but not right now. Just wanna say cheers and loving these recommendations.
Southernraw. Good on ya mate.
I admire your never deviating and enduring passion for Australia’s original inhabitants.
The more I read and the more I learn about them, the more enriched I feel.
There’s a plethora of material out there to read, Adam12 mentioned one I’d not previously heard of, so I will track it down and learn something new. All the best .AW
Some good reading on FNP in this one; People of the River: Lost worlds of early Australia: Australia's earliest settlers by Grace Kaskens. Early days around Hawkesbury, Nepean rivers and the interaction between FNP and colonists - some good, some bad.
saurusv1 wrote:Some good reading on FNP in this one; People of the River: Lost worlds of early Australia: Australia's earliest settlers by Grace Kaskens. Early days around Hawkesbury, Nepean rivers and the interaction between FNP and colonists - some good, some bad.
Saurusv1. Hi mate. Cheers for that, I will track them down.
Because of the intentional motives of the Australian education systems post 1950’s , we were all devoid of any sound knowledge of our original inhabitants , disgusting really.
In primary and secondary school, I/we were taught nothing at all except for a bit about James Cook.
So the more I hear and read from recommendations here on SWNT , the more I hope to learn.
Have a good day. AW
There’s also some evidence of pre-colonial contact between the Bundjalung nation and the Khmer empire. There’s so much more research that needs to be done on this.
https://thehistoryofculture.wordpress.com/2021/06/16/ancient-hindu-marin...
AlfredWallace wrote:saurusv1 wrote:Some good reading on FNP in this one; People of the River: Lost worlds of early Australia: Australia's earliest settlers by Grace Kaskens. Early days around Hawkesbury, Nepean rivers and the interaction between FNP and colonists - some good, some bad.
Saurusv1. Hi mate. Cheers for that, I will track them down.
Because of the intentional motives of the Australian education systems post 1950’s , we were all devoid of any sound knowledge of our original inhabitants , disgusting really.
In primary and secondary school, I/we were taught nothing at all except for a bit about James Cook.
So the more I hear and read from recommendations here on SWNT , the more I hope to learn.
Have a good day. AW
I hear/read people say this a lot, but it wasn't my experience.
I went to primary school in the 80s, high school late 80s early 90s.
And i recall both in primary and high school learning about Aboriginal people and way of life, i dont think it was in depth or focussing on negatives like masacares or definitely not stolen generation, more just culture in hunting, ceremony, arts, shelter and the cliche stuff didgeridoo's, boomerangs, dreamtime etc
I even recall on a school camp having to build shelters based on what we had learnt and in art doing dot paintings.
Then in high school i recall learning in social science about local Aboriginal people and pointing out things like where there is midens etc
Went to school in Tassie for 10,11,12 I dont recall learning anything about Aboriginal people then, but then again i dont recall learning anything at all then, but they must have learnt Aboriginal stuff there too because one of my good mates got the nick name Truganini/Nini because he got 10/10 for an assignment on Truganini the last Aboriginal in Tasmania, and he already had the nick name by the time i met him.
It's funny because i remember this stuff better than i do learning about Captain Cook or the first fleet, Convicts etc, i found that stuff kind of boring, it was only Burke and Wills etc that i found more interesting as they went into the outback.
I think i remember the Aboriginal stuff better because i was one of those kids that loved nature, always searching for lizards and frogs etc and loved watching Harry Buttler, Leyland brothers, World Safari movies, Alby Mangles, Malcom Douglas .
Man i loved that shit and the Aboriginal aspect played a decent part in a lot of those series.
^^^Huh?
High school ended at year 10 in Tassie back then for the vast majority of students, if you wanted to go to year 12 you could but typically had to move to a small number of high schools and the extra 2 years were seen as only needed for the academically minded students wanting to go to university …. now that doesn’t sound like you does it @info so maybe your memory is not as good as you may think or ….
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-08-07/all-tasmanian-high-schools-extend...
indo-dreaming wrote:AlfredWallace wrote:saurusv1 wrote:Some good reading on FNP in this one; People of the River: Lost worlds of early Australia: Australia's earliest settlers by Grace Kaskens. Early days around Hawkesbury, Nepean rivers and the interaction between FNP and colonists - some good, some bad.
Saurusv1. Hi mate. Cheers for that, I will track them down.
Because of the intentional motives of the Australian education systems post 1950’s , we were all devoid of any sound knowledge of our original inhabitants , disgusting really.
In primary and secondary school, I/we were taught nothing at all except for a bit about James Cook.
So the more I hear and read from recommendations here on SWNT , the more I hope to learn.
Have a good day. AWI hear/read people say this a lot, but it wasn't my experience.
I went to primary school in the 80s, high school late 80s early 90s.
And i recall both in primary and high school learning about Aboriginal people and way of life, i dont think it was in depth or focussing on negatives like masacares or definitely not stolen generation, more just culture in hunting, ceremony, arts, shelter and the cliche stuff didgeridoo's, boomerangs, dreamtime etc
I even recall on a school camp having to build shelters based on what we had learnt and in art doing dot paintings.
Then in high school i recall learning in social science about local Aboriginal people and pointing out things like where there is midens etc
Went to school in Tassie for 10,11,12 I dont recall learning anything about Aboriginal people then, but then again i dont recall learning anything at all then, but they must have learnt Aboriginal stuff there too because one of my good mates got the nick name Truganini/Nini because he got 10/10 for an assignment on Truganini the last Aboriginal in Tasmania, and he already had the nick name by the time i met him.
It's funny because i remember this stuff better than i do learning about Captain Cook or the first fleet, Convicts etc, i found that stuff kind of boring, it was only Burke and Wills etc that i found more interesting as they went into the outback.
I think i remember the Aboriginal stuff better because i was one of those kids that loved nature, always searching for lizards and frogs etc and loved watching Harry Buttler, Leyland brothers, World Safari movies, Alby Mangles, Malcom Douglas .
Man i loved that shit and the Aboriginal aspect played a decent part in a lot of those series.
IndoDreaming. Hi pal. Good stuff, thanks for sharing.
Thanks heaps for your honest and sound description of your experience at primary and secondary school. Your recollection sounds great, I envy what you learnt.
Herein lies the difference a decade makes.
I went to primary school commencing 1970, complete doughnuts of anything that resembled any understanding of aboriginal history, this continued until I left high school in 1980.
Throughout high school we had Chinese, American and European history classes.
Bored me shitless. Fancy having an education system devoid of knowledge about one, your own country in general, but two, anything about aboriginal history, the history that dictated what we had and what we still have.
Anyway, I’m like you , I remember the aboriginal stuff better also, loved The Leyland Brothers, Malcolm Douglas, Vincent Serventy ( my favourite), Harry Butler, Alby Mangels ( for the racy chicks mostly) and even much later on, Les Hiddins ( Bush Tucker Man, incredible bush plant knowledge, The Army loved him and paid him well, ultimately parting, total piss head).
We loved these shows that mostly filled our Sunday evenings because it gave us a snapshot and a window into Australia which at most of those times was traversed on dirt roads.
We loved them all it as it was a brief glimpse into our own heart of our nation, they brought it to me and I wanted to be where they were. We’ve got a great continent and we should cherish and take care of it.
Last year, Australians spent more money on camping, travelling at home and travelling the new way, where your car is very much part of your home ( i.e Adventure Kings, Anaconda, BCF etc) than ever before.
Life’s, so good. AW
I’m the same vintage.
Crickets about blackfellas history.
I was in Darwin high schools.
Bloody good footy players to play alongside. Many still barefoot back then. Talented!
overthefalls wrote:There’s also some evidence of pre-colonial contact between the Bundjalung nation and the Khmer empire. There’s so much more research that needs to be done on this.
https://thehistoryofculture.wordpress.com/2021/06/16/ancient-hindu-marin...
OTF. Hi fella.
Thanks for another post of interest for us to check out.
There’s some brilliant historical work attributed to many who care. AW
seeds wrote:I’m the same vintage.
Crickets about blackfellas history.
I was in Darwin high schools.
Bloody good footy players to play alongside. Many still barefoot back then. Talented!
Seeds. Hi mate. Hope you going great guns. Apologies, haven’t spoken for.
awhile.
I must say, your ‘night moves’ have been cracking me up, you’ve obviously been on night shift. Some great evening and wee hours dribble,
I , (10 of us actually, all from Geelong and Surf Coast) played football in 1984 in Albany for Railways Football Club. We had two houses, five guys in each, we were always the talk of the town.
Played against Denmark twice a year, nearly all Aboriginal players, They were talented and quick, one game there were 8 players all with the surname Long.
So from the boundary you’d hear their supporters yelling out ‘Go Longy, Go Longy, go, go Longy, go Longy, get it Longy, such fun, very fair players, we always shook hands at the end.
I played half back flank, one game against Mt. Barker, one of the Krakouer boys ( who went onto to play AFL) was on me, forget which one, they and him were so quick.
On one occasion I’m looking around for him and the next thing he’s standing on my shoulders taking a speccy. My mates ribbed me all night back on the beers at the clubrooms. AW
Awesome memories AW! I stopped playing football at 16. Never had the opportunity to do something like that. Sounds like great fun.
I played two seasons in the juniors in Darwin. Assistant coach( not sure if that was official ) was a Longy. Michael Long. He played seniors for St Mary’s. Hooked up with Essedon the next year. Nice young bloke from my memory.
I would say schooling for me was very similar to Indo's, in time and themes. We did the history of Aboriginal Australia, and it was balanced for content with European history in Australia. I am more concerned for the kids in more recent years, ours were not taught in school about the First Fleet, were not taught about Burke and Wills, were not taught the patterns of exploration. They got a great deal of the Aboriginal history, which is good, but commented that this was all they seemed to do. SiL is a teacher and has relayed more recent stories of primary students in tears after being taught the guilt version of interactions, this sounded horrific and I was glad my kids were graduated and not subject to this. Teach it all, and balance it much like it was for Indo and myself.
GuySmiley wrote:^^^Huh?
High school ended at year 10 in Tassie back then for the vast majority of students, if you wanted to go to year 12 you could but typically had to move to a small number of high schools and the extra 2 years were seen as only needed for the academically minded students wanting to go to university …. now that doesn’t sound like you does it @info so maybe your memory is not as good as you may think or ….https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-08-07/all-tasmanian-high-schools-extend...
Kinda true after grade 10 we went to a different school a bit further away they called it a College and it was only 11 & 12 there was even the odd mature student, in one class one lady would have been 60, and it was structured a bit more like Uni, you had topics you could pick and free periods where you were suppose to study, (but hardly anyone did) you rarely did a whole day 9 to 3 and it had a smoking area etc it was pretty relaxed and very social girls and pot, i just went because it was just expected from parents and pretty much all my mates went, it was pretty much the default thing to do.
And the narrative at that time was if you didnt do year 12 you would never get a job.
The majority of kids i went to school with in year 10 went on and did 11 & 12 maybe 10 to 20% max went and did Tafe and maybe 10 to 20% of kids at the end of year 10 went and did an apprenticeship or some even got a job, i wish i did a apprenticeship then but it was pretty hard times Labor's recession was hitting and Tassie was completely dead even without a recession, those that did get an apprenticeship or job were generally well connected.
Doing 11 & 12 was pretty much a waste of time though i did fuck all mostly art subjects, the bus went along the coast and if there was waves a lot of time i went to a few classes then i hitched home with a mate snuck my board and went surfing, or if it was really pumping very rare i even hitched straight back home. (parents always got pissed off at me, but it was worth it, i have such great memories of those times)
I remember lots of friends at the end of year ten talking about going to Uni something i had no interest in, lots of my good mates who surfed were pretty academic but it's weird once year 12 ended none of them went on to university they either moved to Vic*, QLD or WA those that stayed in the area got a job or apprenticeship as well connected growing up there all their life's one or two went on to do Tafe.
* I brought three mates back with me to the Island.
^^ good one, thanks
velocityjohnno wrote:I would say schooling for me was very similar to Indo's, in time and themes. We did the history of Aboriginal Australia, and it was balanced for content with European history in Australia. I am more concerned for the kids in more recent years, ours were not taught in school about the First Fleet, were not taught about Burke and Wills, were not taught the patterns of exploration. They got a great deal of the Aboriginal history, which is good, but commented that this was all they seemed to do. SiL is a teacher and has relayed more recent stories of primary students in tears after being taught the guilt version of interactions, this sounded horrific and I was glad my kids were graduated and not subject to this. Teach it all, and balance it much like it was for Indo and myself.
VelocityJohnno. Hi pal. Hope your whole clan is well.
Agree totally, teach it all, after all it is ‘our’ history both the original and current occupants.
Not forgetting the history of other international explorers to come here, early French and Dutch mariners, Houtman , the Batavia boat and massacre, Baudin,
I’m very much an ‘I am, You Are, We Are Australian’ kind of guy, alas my heart still lies with aboriginal history, mostly because of their link to the land and all biota, but that’s just my view.
I would have loved to have seen the Australian natural landscape prior to European settlement.
Alas, I can also gain similar satisfaction about hearing of the deeds of Gregory, Burke & Wills and so on.
Xavier Herbert wrote in my opinion very accurate accounts of early Australian History. Some would agree, others may not. AW
@AW,
Ha, you were in the crew I stood watching build the steps at Impossos one day years ago! Classic. I think I even had a chat with some of them.
What a place hey.
Been going there since the days of the old tip road, probably you did the same.
And yep, Buckley country. What that man saw and did. Pity he never wrote about it himself.
My brother is a Buckley encyclopedia, got every book ever published about him. I'm sure I have probably read that John Morgan book you mentioned.
And although I knew why and accepted it, I was pissed off when they changed the carpark at Outsides.
I used to love sitting in my car up on that berm checking that vista, spent a lot of my life there back in the day, probably unknowingly parked on a midden.
That place...
Memory flash , the big Simon Saturday at Bells I surfed Outers late that afternoon, the swell had peaked during the day but that was a golden afternoon and sunset, not a drop out of place, butter, and a ruler straight powerful and still pretty fkn big swell. My girlfriend sitting in the bench front seat of my EH wagon parked up on the berm as I left the water, her and the car interior lit up with the sunset backdrop light. She was beautiful, glowing. I'd just had one of the sessions of my life...I have no memory of it but I'd bet the house there was some sex involved not long after...as was my wicked way at the time...
Some days in your life you just want to forget and never live again, some days you'd do over forever.
A lot of my do over days would be at that place.
And what a guy you are @AW, constructor, custodian, contributor, naturalist, knowledge spreader!
And so polite!
"He built the steps to Impossos"
That alone is a worthy epitaph for any Vicco surfer.
Like building the stairway to heaven.
Yarrr!!!
AlfredWallace wrote:seeds wrote:I’m the same vintage.
Crickets about blackfellas history.
I was in Darwin high schools.
Bloody good footy players to play alongside. Many still barefoot back then. Talented!Seeds. Hi mate. Hope you going great guns. Apologies, haven’t spoken for.
awhile.
I must say, your ‘night moves’ have been cracking me up, you’ve obviously been on night shift. Some great evening and wee hours dribble,I , (10 of us actually, all from Geelong and Surf Coast) played football in 1984 in Albany for Railways Football Club. We had two houses, five guys in each, we were always the talk of the town.
Played against Denmark twice a year, nearly all Aboriginal players, They were talented and quick, one game there were 8 players all with the surname Long.
So from the boundary you’d hear their supporters yelling out ‘Go Longy, Go Longy, go, go Longy, go Longy, get it Longy, such fun, very fair players, we always shook hands at the end.
I played half back flank, one game against Mt. Barker, one of the Krakouer boys ( who went onto to play AFL) was on me, forget which one, they and him were so quick.
On one occasion I’m looking around for him and the next thing he’s standing on my shoulders taking a speccy. My mates ribbed me all night back on the beers at the clubrooms. AW
The Rails eh!! haha classic stuff AW.
It's the one and only time you'll see me say up the Maggies!!
haha.
Very enjoyable reading above from all.
Did someone mention "Krakouer boys "
Andrew Krakouer was a joy to watch, and it's just a great feel good story having a second chance at AFL, just a pity he didn't get the premiership medal he deserved in 2011
adam12 wrote:@AW,
Ha, you were in the crew I stood watching build the steps at Impossos one day years ago! Classic. I think I even had a chat with some of them.
What a place hey.
Been going there since the days of the old tip road, probably you did the same.
And yep, Buckley country. What that man saw and did. Pity he never wrote about it himself.
My brother is a Buckley encyclopedia, got every book ever published about him. I'm sure I have probably read that John Morgan book you mentioned.
And although I knew why and accepted it, I was pissed off when they changed the carpark at Outsides.
I used to love sitting in my car up on that berm checking that vista, spent a lot of my life there back in the day, probably unknowingly parked on a midden.
That place...
Memory flash , the big Simon Saturday at Bells I surfed Outers late that afternoon, the swell had peaked during the day but that was a golden afternoon and sunset, not a drop out of place, butter, and a ruler straight powerful and still pretty fkn big swell. My girlfriend sitting in the bench front seat of my EH wagon parked up on the berm as I left the water, her and the car interior lit up with the sunset backdrop light. She was beautiful, glowing. I'd just had one of the sessions of my life...I have no memory of it but I'd bet the house there was some sex involved not long after...as was my wicked way at the time...
Some days in your life you just want to forget and never live again, some days you'd do over forever.
A lot of my do over days would be at that place.
And what a guy you are @AW, constructor, custodian, contributor, naturalist, knowledge spreader!
And so polite!
"He built the steps to Impossos"
That alone is a worthy epitaph for any Vicco surfer.
Like building the stairway to heaven.
Yarrr!!!
Adam12. Hi pal. Hope you, your brother and father are riding our silky tropospheric Summer waves of heat of late.
I’m guessing, the more you and I write the more Swellnet folk thinks we are the same person. Maybe I’m Heeby and you’re, well Jeeby or I’m Well hang and you’re Juliang.
Fucking glad that identity crisis is well over, when you put psilocybins back in your study desk drawer for another year, things can run smoothly again ExxotixJeff.
What the fuck was that all about ?
I do like building stuff, it’s personally very satisfying, I like design, natural or fabricated by imagination.
There were days at Possos when I felt a real connection, being privy to reading the Archeological Survey Report, the place was vibrant and alive when occupied by Buckley and the Wadda Wurrung people.
When we meet soon I’ll fill you in entirely.
I was abused a few times by surfers whilst working there, mostly along the same lines as you mentioned, Outers car park.
On one account, this guy is right in my face and says, what the fuck are you doing, I said restoring/protecting sensitive archeological history, he goes, well what about our Surfing History, I paused briefly and gave him both barrels of , what fucking history, all 60 years of it, gives us a break mate. He fucked off, tail between his skinny no arse, piss heads body.
I’ve decades of memories from Possos and plenty of ‘Stairways to Heaven’ and seeing ‘Paradise By The Dashboard Light’ moments , taking young women for ‘driving and parking ‘ lessons at inners car park, we always had one hand on the ‘park brake’ if you know what I mean.
It still has a real sense of place, day or night.
I nearly died a few times on the old gravel tip road which you could drive straight through to Torquay. A couple of those sneaky curves had the Volksie up on two wheels at times.
Great place for smoking and selling weed also.
These days I rarely surf there, I observe and count bird species for citizens science input.
One year I had a big blue with Doug ‘Claw’ Warbrick of Rip Curl fame.
I gets out of his car and storms over as we were planting some of the last local flora plants.
I’m not happy with all this work, we/ I were going to build a two story metal viewing platform for a World Champion Longboard competition, I said no you’re not.
You’d require Federal change to Archaeological Survey legislation, good luck, called me a smart arse. He went on a rant about how his company is a coastal custodian and all this shit, I laughed, he was fuming, I said custodian and carers of the coast my arse, look at your bloody Rip Curl headquarters office gardens, all Silver Birches, English Box plants and White Iceberg roses, nothing resembles local flora at all.
Consequently he wrote a letter to Surfrider Foundation HQ complaining about ‘ your guy’, me.
He went on to say where did some or all of the money come from for the Possos work we did, inadvertently they’d donated $10K a year earlier and had forgotten about it, I was pissing myself.
My job in Geelong starts on Tuesday, I’ve got 10 days demolition and rough in. Tiler will be waterproofing for one week and tiling for two weeks, very fiddly tiles.
I’ll keep you posted about painting.
So looking forward to meeting and working with you. Can’t see us getting much done some days.
Great to chat as always. AW
southernraw wrote:AlfredWallace wrote:seeds wrote:I’m the same vintage.
Crickets about blackfellas history.
I was in Darwin high schools.
Bloody good footy players to play alongside. Many still barefoot back then. Talented!Seeds. Hi mate. Hope you going great guns. Apologies, haven’t spoken for.
awhile.
I must say, your ‘night moves’ have been cracking me up, you’ve obviously been on night shift. Some great evening and wee hours dribble,I , (10 of us actually, all from Geelong and Surf Coast) played football in 1984 in Albany for Railways Football Club. We had two houses, five guys in each, we were always the talk of the town.
Played against Denmark twice a year, nearly all Aboriginal players, They were talented and quick, one game there were 8 players all with the surname Long.
So from the boundary you’d hear their supporters yelling out ‘Go Longy, Go Longy, go, go Longy, go Longy, get it Longy, such fun, very fair players, we always shook hands at the end.
I played half back flank, one game against Mt. Barker, one of the Krakouer boys ( who went onto to play AFL) was on me, forget which one, they and him were so quick.
On one occasion I’m looking around for him and the next thing he’s standing on my shoulders taking a speccy. My mates ribbed me all night back on the beers at the clubrooms. AWThe Rails eh!! haha classic stuff AW.
It's the one and only time you'll see me say up the Maggies!!
haha.
Very enjoyable reading above from all.
Southernraw. Right around your corner. Hi mate.
Rails, yeah, we definitely went off the rails, cops hated us.
Might have been a few nasal rails ingested also.
We one the flag in 1984, I played seconds, me other mates , big guys played firsts.
We had two houses of ill repute and all the towns young crew loved us, especially the ‘lady’ types. Unbridled youth, may it never fade into oblivion. AW
indo-dreaming wrote:Did someone mention "Krakouer boys "
Andrew Krakouer was a joy to watch, and it's just a great feel good story having a second chance at AFL, just a pity he didn't get the premiership medal he deserved in 2011
IndoDreaming. Hi mate.
He was a joy to watch, I agree.
That entire Krakouer family had footy mega stars. They could fly high or run like the wind. AW
AlfredWallace wrote:southernraw wrote:AlfredWallace wrote:seeds wrote:I’m the same vintage.
Crickets about blackfellas history.
I was in Darwin high schools.
Bloody good footy players to play alongside. Many still barefoot back then. Talented!Seeds. Hi mate. Hope you going great guns. Apologies, haven’t spoken for.
awhile.
I must say, your ‘night moves’ have been cracking me up, you’ve obviously been on night shift. Some great evening and wee hours dribble,I , (10 of us actually, all from Geelong and Surf Coast) played football in 1984 in Albany for Railways Football Club. We had two houses, five guys in each, we were always the talk of the town.
Played against Denmark twice a year, nearly all Aboriginal players, They were talented and quick, one game there were 8 players all with the surname Long.
So from the boundary you’d hear their supporters yelling out ‘Go Longy, Go Longy, go, go Longy, go Longy, get it Longy, such fun, very fair players, we always shook hands at the end.
I played half back flank, one game against Mt. Barker, one of the Krakouer boys ( who went onto to play AFL) was on me, forget which one, they and him were so quick.
On one occasion I’m looking around for him and the next thing he’s standing on my shoulders taking a speccy. My mates ribbed me all night back on the beers at the clubrooms. AWThe Rails eh!! haha classic stuff AW.
It's the one and only time you'll see me say up the Maggies!!
haha.
Very enjoyable reading above from all.Southernraw. Right around your corner. Hi mate.
Rails, yeah, we definitely went off the rails, cops hated us.
Might have been a few nasal rails ingested also.
We one the flag in 1984, I played seconds, me other mates , big guys played firsts.We had two houses of ill repute and all the towns young crew loved us, especially the ‘lady’ types. Unbridled youth, may it never fade into oblivion. AW
Hey AW. Was Alan Wattling the coach back then?
GuySmiley wrote:^^^Huh?
High school ended at year 10 in Tassie back then for the vast majority of students, if you wanted to go to year 12 you could but typically had to move to a small number of high schools and the extra 2 years were seen as only needed for the academically minded students wanting to go to university …. now that doesn’t sound like you does it @info so maybe your memory is not as good as you may think or ….https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-08-07/all-tasmanian-high-schools-extend...
GuySmiley. Hi mate.
Late reply, sorry.
My brother on King Island, his daughters were only able to go up to year 10 under Tasmanian education system.
They had to leave the island and attend 11 and 12 in Burnie, NW Tassie. AW
@AW
"My job in Geelong starts on Tuesday, I’ve got 10 days demolition and rough in. Tiler will be waterproofing for one week and tiling for two weeks, very fiddly tiles.
I’ll keep you posted about painting."
Look forward to it @AW, just let me know and I'll be there.
Good Claw story.
Bummer he was like that to you, bit disappointing really.
I always got on pretty well with him, he was one of the few of that TQ mafia that used to come up and hunt the beachies up the far end of the Bellarine. I had some good chats with him a few times, Simon Buttonshaw was another I used to run into up that way, such a nice guy and legend. Bummer he's pretty crook at the moment.
Most of those TQ guys never went past Beacon unless they were going over to that left that likes a southerly.
Anyway, looks like you've got convo's and catch ups going on all over the shop here @AW, very popular, great stuff!
I'll let you go and catch you soon.
The last two days of discussion here has seen me having flashbacks; I hope to be brief.
I studied Australian History in my senior years at high school and for 2 years at uni (Manning Clark and Geoffrey Blainey works mainly and much of their original notes). It wasn't really until uni that I was made aware of the dark history of our FNPs. Its changed now thank goodness.
My memory of Pt Impossible goes back to the tip road, the old iron dunny and the hazardous scramble over the rocks before the steps. Like @adam12 ^^ our favourite car parking /van camping spot was on the midden not knowing what we were doing; I can still see the layers of shells on the eroded dune where cars drove. I learnt to surf there pretty much and have had many fantastic days out over the decades at Outers with overhead bombs refracting across the reef, paying dues and getting rewarded. Mmmm, smoked my first joint there, it didn't affect me at all, honest. @AW hats off to up those steps have stood the test of time and ocean. Its only the last 20 or so years I became aware of William Buckley's history there.
@souhernraw and @aw yesterday spoke to the energy or connection of country. I'm guessing we all have connection to places/times but I want to speak of energy. On a trip to the south coast years ago we stayed at Cape Conran and one afternoon I went for a walk along this coastal trail. After a short while I realised I was walking extremely slowly, silently, as if I was doing a walking mediation and I had this sense that everything around me (trees, the ground and shoreline rocks) seemed to bearing witness to my presence, it was as if I was being watched. It was if I was sort of tripping but most definitely I wasn't. I was hyper alert to everything in the environment but ever so slowly I was being drawn further down as I walked further around the point. I found myself on a beach marvelling at the energy that created these beautifully rounded granite pebbles and as I stood there the hair on my body suddenly stood up and I thought someone was standing behind me. That spooked me proper and I retraced my steps quicker than before but now with the sense there must be some sorry business history there. On returning from the trip I researched the area and found the path/boardwalk I was on protected middens dating back over 10,000 years and that whole Cape, Snowy, Marlo area has multiple massacres sites from the mid 1800's. I can't rationalise what happened that day at all ........
Uni assignment i did a few years ago. This is my take on things. I'm sure this will ruffle many feathers. I hope so.
Love Blue Diamond x
The Necessity of Reparation for Historic Injustices
Introduction – Compensatory Justice
Disparities between the standards of living of humans on this planet have long been a part of our history on this planet. From the wealthy nations of the West to the developing and undeveloped nations on this globe, the diversity in the quality of life when viewed from a moral standpoint are without a doubt grossly unfair.
In this paper I will look at why historic injustices do require some form of reparation. I take a strong stance that we are more obliged to solve current injustices than to provide reparation for every act of injustice in the past. In doing this I will first investigate the historic injustice of the Aboriginal people of Australia and I will look at the argument that they are entitled to some form of reparation and why.
I will incoroporate some interesting views from Jeremy Waldron, Robert Nozick and others which will help me slowly build to my conclusion that reparation should be in the form of Non Indigenous Australians surrendering some of our priveleges as a form of reparation.
Historic Injustices to Indigenous Australians:
Australia the continent was well inhabited for many years long before white settlement. It is commonly known that in 1788 Australia was colonised as a country under the rule of the British Empire, with total contempt for the fact that it was already inhabited by a native indigenous race of people.
The way the original inhabitants have been treated, including forced assimilation, execution, stolen families and not even allowed to be recognised as citizens for a large part of white Australia’s history are also well known facts. (Poole, 1999,pp114-142)
There exists now a situation where there is a large divide between Aboriginal and non Aboriginal Australian’s that can be traced back to the moment Australia was invaded by English settlers and the brutal and unfair treatment that has followed.
So at this point now, in 2013 what is the just and fair way to make amends for past actions?
I would argue that a moderate to large amount of reparation is overdue for this nation of people, the Aboriginal people. But there are many challenges to this view point especially that of how much reparation, and what sort of compensation.
Past injustices or present suffering?
One of the questions raised in an issue like this is whether it is better to provide compensation or reparation for past deeds, which have already been done in a previous generation and cannot be changed, or whether it is better to now provide assistance to those who are suffering in their current situations and consider that as a form of moral duty.
To understand this we need to delve a little deeper into this issue and hear some differing viewpoints.
Firstly we need to understand what the best way to provide reparation. How do we judge what is the best way of giving back and how much? Jeremy Waldron states “The historic record has a fragility that consists, …in the sheer contingency of what happened in the past” (Waldron,1992,p5 )
This is saying that we can’t trace every single injustice back to the original act therefore reparation for every act would be almost impossible because it would ultimately be guess work.
In this statement he has an objection from Robert Nozick who believes it is in fact possible to address this problem by “changing the present so that it resembles how the past would have looked had the injustice not taken place” (McKenzie, 2013)
This would be a way to ultimately provide maximum reparation, but is it the correct approach? I believe this is a fairly radical approach, although it does have some merits in the fact it would be working in a positive way for indigenous people, I don’t think it is entirely the right way to deal with these issues but it is on the right track.
Waldron argues that it is based on too many unknowns. “The status of counterfactual reasoning about the exercising of human reasoning of human freedom is unclear”(Waldron 1993,p10)
Which leaves the question somewhat open about the sort of reparation that is required, but provides one clear answer to the key question. Both agree that yes, reparation to some extent is required. But how much and in what form?
Another philosopher who leans more towards Waldron’s views is Kymlicka. He is somewhat more straightforward in his assessment that property rights in particular for Aboriginals would create “massive unfairness” and also he maintains the argument “Aboriginal rights must be grounded in concerns about equality and contemporary disadvantage. (McKenzie, 2013) I agree with both these views but I don’t think they provide any active solutions.
The Solution?
So if its not handing back all of Australia’s land to the original inhabitants that is the most appropriate way to deal with past injustices, then what is?
I look at the current country I grew up in, as a white Australian. I ask myself why I never had Aboriginal friends growing up, no understanding of Aboriginal culture and why my basic understanding of Indigenous Australians is mostly 200 years old. I look at our flag, a symbol of a nation that stole a country from its original inhabitants, with no recognition of the Indigenous people at all on it. I see that Australia considered Indigenous people as less than people until only 40 years ago and I see the way that Indigenous Australians live a completely separate life to the way of life I know as an Australian. I see that the only indigenous politician I am aware of is a former Olympian and it is because of this fact of her sporting status that I know this. I see no collective power or representation of Indigenous Australians and I see non Indigenous Australians,( a culture built on a history of stealing a land and mistreating its people) still taking, taking as much out of this land as they can, with little to no regard of sharing or giving to the original inhabitants. I see a government that says lots of words about ‘closing the gap’ and bringing the living standards of non- indigenous and indigenous Australians closer together, but apart from nice words, there is no conviction, no follow through, just assimilation , and all that still remains are injustices.
As stated by Sparrow, “Continuity gives rise to responsibility on part of present generations of Australians for our history”.(McKenzie,2013). Although deeds happened in the past beyond our control, what we do now to either ignore, or rectify these issues will reflect on us in history. So if we choose to do nothing, we are contributing to the history of the mistreatment of non- indigenous Australians. And this is simply unacceptable in my opinion.
Conclusion
So what is fair? I believe that the way forward is a surrendering of some of our privileges as non- indigenous Australians. The simple fact is it was morally wrong without a doubt what has happened in the past. And it is also morally wrong without a doubt to ignore these facts and not offer some form of reparation in the present. But how much?
I think that going back to Robert Nozick’s argument is a start. I think Nozick is wrong to make the present resemble the past in every aspect. But I do think that it would be reasonable to restore some aspects of the way things should be. The things that happened in the past were out of our control and we can’t go back to changing the way things were. But we could change the way things are.
For some examples. Why not give at least 50% of political power to indigenous people? It surely would be a fair thing to do considering this is their country. Media control. 50 percent. Industry. Realestate. The list goes on. Why do we not acknowledge the indigenous people on our flag, or better still use their flag? Why is Australia still a part of the Commonwealth when it serves little purpose to any of us and serves as a constant reminder to Indigenous Australians that they are still controlled by the original invaders. These to me are fairly simple reparations that would have minimal impact on Australia as a whole. Perhaps, it would alter the way we live but I think it is our responsibility, morally to forfeit some of our privileges for the greater good. Basically a little bit goes a long way.
In closing, it is a fact that a huge injustice occurred to the Indigenous population and suffering continues to this day. There is no easy solution to such a burden of pain. I believe the only solutions are for the non- Indigenous population to take responsibility and sacrifice our own way of life to bring about an overall equality. Sacrifice is not an easy word. But it all comes down to right and wrong. We are in a position to give, in this current generation. What are we so scared to lose, that was never ours in the first place??
Bibliography
McKenzie,C.”Prof” (2013), Lecture, Historic Injustices and Indigenous Rights, Macquarie University
Poole, R. (1999). Nation and Identity.Routledge, London, pp.114-142
Waldron,J. (1992). ‘Superseding Historic Injustice’. Ethics, 103 (1), 4-28
References
Poole, R. (1999). Nation and Identity.Routledge, London, pp.114-142
Waldron,J. (1992). ‘Superseding Historic Injustice’. Ethics, 103 (1), 4-28