Late Start To Cyclone Season
After an off-kilter start to summer where our easterly trade-wind belt took extended smoko then failed to return, and the standard Northern Australian Monsoon (NAM) has registered its latest start in recorded history* we are finally looking at some action across the tropics.
The BOM-issued Tropical Cyclone outlook was for an average season with eleven cyclones, with four in the Coral Sea. Under La Niña (or La Niña-tending) conditions an early start to the monsoon and TC season was predicted, although the link between monsoon onset is stronger for El Niño years.
Monsoon onset and low pressure development - which is the basis for cyclones - is normally linked to active phases of the Madden-Julian Oscillation (MJO) moving west to east from the Indian Ocean into the Pacific Ocean. We currently have a moderate/strong phase of the MJO moving over northern Australia which is expected to both signal the official start of the monsoon and potentially spawn single or multiple cyclones.
It hasn't been the first active phase of the MJO this season. A strong phase of the MJO in late November/early December bought on the wet season in Indonesia, spawning twin cyclones from low pressures off Sumatra. TC Fengal headed west to bring death and destruction to Sri Lanka and India, while TC Robyn drifted southwards into the Australian Area of Responsibility to become our first named cyclone of the season before washing out near the Cocos Islands after causing lethal flooding and landslides in Indonesia. Monsoonal westerly winds from that event stalled in the Arafura Sea and failed to impact areas to the north of Australia and Coral Sea.
The late-developing La Niña and associated strong trade-wind surges in the tropical Pacific seem to have repelled all previous MJO phases, almost as if the MJO were hitting an impenetrable wall.
Why the late onset? There are no firm answers, only tentative hypotheses. Chief among them a changing climate which is reducing confidence in the timing and amplitude of seasonal norms. Our surf seasons have been affected by these reductions or reversals in typical weather patterns. Tropical low pressure in October for example, a feature of the last several years. Despite an El Niño pattern last year and predictions of lower cyclone frequency and intensity and later onset we saw Category 5 TC Lola develop in October - the earliest Cat 5 storm ever recorded in the South Pacific.
Seasonal predictions may become of diminishing utility as we move further into a new period of changing climate.
One prediction climate scientists have made has so far held true. Overall number of cyclones in the South Pacific, including the Coral Sea has decreased in line with climate predictions.
This increasing seasonal variability and overall trend of fewer cyclones may spell the end of the mythical Christmas cyclone swell, relegated to the stories told by red-blotched faces around the front bar.
Back to the present. A flurry of activity is expected as the wave of tropical instability caused by the MJO pushes across the top end and into the Coral Sea.
The Joint Typhoon Warning Centre is interested in a low due north of Cairns with a high probability for cyclogenesis in the next 24hrs. If this beats a low in the Gulf of Carpenteria to the punch it would be named TC Taliah. Potential also exists for TC's Vince and Zelia to follow. With the current instability along the trough line, confidence remains very low over specific outcomes so don't get too frothed up or disappointed over single model runs - we will see a lot of to and fro through this week and into the weekend.
Of more importance will be the broad easterly windfield supporting the developing low pressure centres which should at a minimum set up a long-lasting drumbeat of pulsey easterly swells.
Keep tabs on the actual surf potential from this set-up in the Northern NSW and Queensland Forecaster Notes over the following days, and also in the comments below the line.
//STEVE SHEARER
*Over 70 years since records began.
Comments
Interesting article. I'm wondering abouth the prediction regarding the numbers of cyclones decreasing in the south pacific. Was this a BOM prediction? All I've ever heard was that cyclones were increasing in both frequency AND strength.
Only climate-change related TC trend prediction I have heard was a decrease in frequency but an increase in strength.
https://www.climatecouncil.org.au/resources/fact-sheet-tropical-cyclones...
I first heard it in conversation with Prof Roger Tomlinson of the Griffith Centre for Coastal Management in the early 2000's.
Since then, it seems to have become a widely adopted position.
Mentioned in this piece. https://news.griffith.edu.au/2023/01/19/half-century-of-cyclone-data-put...“Although%20there%20was%20a%20statistically,tracks%20in%20this%20cluster%20are
Thanks for clarifying guys. I wonder if the same pattern is observed for more local events such as storms. Frequency unchanged but intensity more severe? Probably harder to quantify given how much smaller they are compared to cyclones.
That's certainly been inline with my observations. Although there hasn't been any significant trend increase for the number of seasonal storms, local events have higher precipitation totals in shorter time frames, which is causing more damage (drainage can't cope with short term water volumes etc).
Growing up on the east coast as a kid. Summer storms and days to weeks of heavy rain in Feb quite common around the old zone.
Modelling* commissioned by my employer (an insurer) suggests:
1) Decrease in the frequency of winter East Coast Lows with decrease strongest at higher global emissions scenarios.
2) Increase in rainfall intensity during storms (anywhere from 5-20% increase in intensity per degree of warming).
3) Change in wind intensity, geographic size and pressure level of storm systems is unclear
4) Decrease in cyclone frequency, especially for WA, with decreases mainly in smaller systems
(CAT 1-3). Projected changes in the larger systems (CAT 4-5) unclear. Future decades may bring fewer cyclones overall but when they do hit, they may be stronger in severity
5) There is a potential for cyclones to slow down in forward speed, see their total footprint area of damaging wind speeds grow, and increase in their maximum gust speed
6) Poleward expansion of cyclone systems and increase in rainfall intensity associated with cyclones (as with storm, flood & hail)
* Remembering that projections relating to extreme weather remain uncertain
cyclogenesis = is a word I dont hear enough
The tropical depressions currently in question..
I’m thinking most of these tropical lows/TCs progged over the next week or two will get whisked away to the SPCZ. And if no supporting high below then not a huge amount of swell potential from the TCs then. The high itself looks to be the bigger swell producer in terms of swell height and longevity.
Can anyone tell me of anywhere on the planet where the Surf quality/quantity has actually improved since the 70s and is likely to keep improving? (Vague suggestions only ofcourse. Promise i wont tell anyone)
Homebush, Tullamarine, Abu Dhabi, Lemoore,...
This is a difficult question to answer, because you also have to factor in advancements such as technology (surfboards, wetsuits) as well as accessibility (roads, boats, airlines) plus the perennial debate on surf forecasting.
Many of the 'great' waves of the 70's have shifted down the bucket-list scale. Meanwhile, surf spots that were never given a second look at, as recently as the 90's and early 00's, are now part of the weekly social media highlight reel.
Nevertheless, this is a fascinating talking point.
Anyway, here's an article Craig wrote fourteen and a half years ago (!) on Skeleton Bay:
https://www.swellnet.com/news/surfpolitik/2012/09/28/skeleton-bay-death-...
Totally agree, mutant slabs and tow ins / step offs are all the rage, hence Nates slab tour and JJF taking a year off...
The long walls of Ulus caught surfers imagination in the 70's...a few years ago the focus transferred to canggu, black t-shirt and boardies de rigueur, crew attempting (and mostly failing) airs...
paddling big waves will never go out of style, but that's not everyones cup of tea
NSW over the last 4 years of La Niña dominated patterns.
Superbank?
Surf quality/quantity is a relative measure. A grom will froth at 2ft.
In North Qld, the trades winds would blow every afternoon and deliver at 3ft mushberger & the locals still surf some bays today.
Big wave chargers seem to want the next big thing... for a dopamine fix.
If I was a teen with P plates or retired, Id say every surf beach in Oz on a hot summer day, is an improvement to school, work, Uni, TAFE, Mc'malls, hot tar burbs, chlorine soaked pools, etc .
Skeleton Bay
Sunny coast is bleak lately
Does this lack of swell in prime season indicate that autumn as well will be poor? It deadset feels like we can’t get waves so bad it’s been
Deadset, there will be waves up your way next week. Heaps of sealife floating around atm.
SE winds will blow in the bluebottles & other current creatures though. Lycra has its uses.
Haha hope so, I’ve lost hope would be stoked to be wrong
What's the explanation for decreasing tropical storm frequency? I suspect something to do with wind shear?
Yep, wind shear and a couple of other factors...
"TCs can form only when an initial circulation is protected from environmental wind shear and dry air intrusions, within which prolonged deep convection can moisten the protected region sufficiently to allow a precursor to develop into a TC..
Even in the current climate, much of the tropics are typically hostile to TC formation with the middle troposphere being too dry and wind shear often too strong. In a warming climate, changes in deep convection, wind shear and middle tropospheric humidity are likely to contribute to an even more hostile TC formation environment globally."
With the warming atmosphere, it can hold more moisture which in turn results in a drop in the relative humidity, inhibiting tropical cyclone formation. Interesting eh.
Also there has been some evidence that the SWP is experiencing a slowing of the Walker Circulation due to climate change i.e moving to more El Nino like state.
At the same time though, sea surface temperatures are rising exponentially from climate change so more energy available for TCs when they do form. Climate change is accelerating making modelling into the future full of uncertainties for extreme events like TCs. Traditional El Nino/ La Nina patterns may not be reliable.
I appreciate the long term outlook forecasts from swellnet, I mean predicting next weeks swell is tricky enough let alone trying to predict what the next 3 montha may look like.
The win for us WA surfers is la Nina didn't kick into gear and there has been consistent 6 - 10ft swells all summer , imo it has been the best summer for many many years. Hopefully Autumn continues this trend with light winds to top it off, yeeeew !
I think Northern NSW/QLD got enough waves during all those lanina's to share a few with the southern states this summer.