Clearing the rafters: One of Australia's best board collections to be sold

Stu Nettle picture
Stu Nettle (stunet)
Swellnet Dispatch

screen_shot_2014-10-10_at_2.35.48_pm.pngThis coming weekend one of Australia's best surfboard collections will be sold at auction. The collection includes one-of-a-kind boards from Bob McTavish, Terry Fitzgerald, and Mark Richards, and while some of the boards have been restored all of them hold historical significance in one way or another. The collection belongs to veteran WA surfer Richard Hadley.

Richard is a fanatical gatherer - he also collects fishing reels, rods, and marine items such as outboard motors - and he had grand plans for his horded goods. Unfortunately he was stymied by local government and the boards will now go under the auctioneer's hammer. Collectors everywhere are in a tizz, many visiting their bank manager and booking tickets to Perth this weekend.

Swellnet spoke to Richard to find out some backstory.

Swellnet: How long have you been collecting surfboards?
Richard Hadley: I first started in 1986. I had an old caravan park down in Smiths Beach, near Yallingup, and I put a restaurant in and I started decorating it with a nautical theme and surfboards. That's where it started from. I sold the restaurant in 2005 and my plan was to open up a museum on some land that we had between Dunsborough and Yallingup. But after six years of angst with councils I'm going to sell off the collection.

So is it with some regret that you're selling your boards?
It was a dream to have had the museum. It would have have displayed boards and had another area with a picture theatre and then also travelling exhibitions or whatever else. And we also had a brewery, that was gonna have a 100 seat restaurant in it. I had people lined up to run the brewery and I'd just about signed the building contract when the council said, well, by the way, you can only have 20 people in your restaurant at any one time otherwise you've gotta get it rezoned.

So we got it rezoned, they passed it, but then the last straw was when they came back to me and said they wanted 161 car bays, all bitumen paved and drained, and they also wanted 56 bicycle racks.

It was the straw that broke the camels back. I just said, this is too hard so unfortunately I'm selling the collection.

screen_shot_2014-10-10_at_2.27.42_pm.pngWere you a very dedicated collector from the beginning?
Well, initially I started collecting fishing rods. I had a lot of antique reels and fly rods and marine stuff, as well as surfboards. And that was all décor for the restaurant. People used to love it. They'd say it was fabulous. And then it just went from there.

Originally I just bought local boards but then I started travelling a lot more, first to the East Coast, and then I started buying a lot through Von Weirdos and from the auctions at Noosa, I did a couple of trips to California, and then a few trips to Hawaii. So that's how I finished up getting what I got.

How's the second hand market for these boards? Think your boards will have increased in value?
I don't know, I'll tell you that after the auction. But I think these sort of things always have a market. I've got a lot of one off stuff and most of it is in pretty good nick. I haven’t just gone out and bought stuff for $300, I've always been pretty discerning. And the longer I've gone on the more discerning I've got.

screen_shot_2014-10-10_at_2.26.11_pm.pngSo you've spent money on boards you really wanted?
Oh yeah. The whole lot, with the memorabilia and all that, it'd be over [amount removed at Richard's request] I've outlaid.

I had an 80 seat restaurant and people who knew nothing about the boards would come in and marvel at them. And they are works of art, aren’t they? They're amazing. No two are the same. That's what got me going, and as I said I had a great fishing reel and fly rod collection which I sold about 10 years ago. I've still got the marine collection, outboard motors and all sorts of bits and pieces like that.

Do you have an opinion on riding old surfboards, Richard? Should they be ridden or hung on a wall?
Ridden. They should be ridden, except for the really old boards. I've got a couple of Wayne Deane's I love riding, and as you'd know Wayne makes a really nice board.

But you've got some very rare boards in your collection, would you advocate riding them?
Oh....yeah....but a lot of the real older boards don’t perform as well as the new ones of course, what with the weight and that. My first surfboard was a hollow wooden one and my first fibreglass board was a Barry Bennett, it probably weighed 25 pounds in the old days. A lot of the boards got up to 30 pounds in the old days. You'd need one kid at each end carrying it down the beach.

screen_shot_2014-10-10_at_2.30.24_pm.pngOK, the boards you're selling, are they your whole collection or just a select part of it?
No, it's a select part, that's probably the best way to describe it. I've gone through it, there's a couple of one offs here and there: the Bunker Spreckels board, a couple of McTavish's, and the Corky Carroll board, they're all one offs. There are some interesting ones there.

What will you do with the ones you're holding onto?
Well I'll probably do another auction later on.

Really..?
Yeah, well what I don't want to do is kill this auction but I've got over 200 more boards.

Are they equally as unique?
They've all got something going for them. Of course there's no more Bunker Spreckels or boards like that, or the Bob McTavish one he did with Morey Pope, there's no more like that, but there's still some lovely boards in the collection.

screen_shot_2014-10-10_at_2.29.54_pm.pngWho did the pricing for this collection? Because the estimated price seemed to be a lot lower than what would reasonably be expected.
Yeah, yeah, the auctioneer advised me not to go too high because then all of a sudden you've got a dead auction. He said the good boards will get their price anyway regardless of what the estimate is. For instance, at Randy Rarick's auction he'd have no reserve. He'd have estimated value but no reserve. I had to listen to the auctioneer, and he said that if you've got people bidding it'll get whatever price it gets.

You mentioned Randy Rarick, have you had any contact from overseas buyers?
We only just started publicising it. It only went onto the website three or four days ago. Again, the auctioneer said you don't go in too early or people get a bit blasé so I listened to his advice. The website only went up this week.

Well already there's been a lot of excitement surrounding the auction. Few fellas I know are checking their bank accounts.
Well that's good. The money is is going to go toward a resort I'm developing. I've got an acre and a half that was kept off the old caravan park and it's in prime location right on Smiths Beach, facing north, and I've got a DA to build apartments there.

No problems with the council then?
Ha...no, not at this stage.

All the best with the auction Richard. Let's have a chat when it's over.
Thanks. Yeah, let's speak then.

Salivate over Richard's soon to be sold boards here.

Comments

top-to-bottom-bells's picture
top-to-bottom-bells's picture
top-to-bottom-bells Monday, 13 Oct 2014 at 10:09am

Who even knew that such a great collection existed in Australia?? It's the Guggenheim of the surfing world and I wish I had the coin to buy a piece.

jaytwovic's picture
jaytwovic's picture
jaytwovic Monday, 13 Oct 2014 at 11:20am

The council has made sure that this great collection will be dispersed never to be see by anyone. Anybody who has dealt with council in Australia feels the pain of Richard Hadley. Sounds like it would have been a great attraction! Shame on council!

zenagain's picture
zenagain's picture
zenagain Monday, 13 Oct 2014 at 11:41am

Agreed, I'd rather see the museum. Shame to see the colection broken up. Just so sweet looking through the auction site.

stunet's picture
stunet's picture
stunet Monday, 13 Oct 2014 at 11:45am

I've been to the Torquay Surf Museum and the one on the Goldy too, both have the odd historically significant board hanging on the walls but imagine a place where all these boards could hang.

Where's a stinkin' rich philanthropist when you need one?

udo's picture
udo's picture
udo Monday, 13 Oct 2014 at 12:40pm

What $$ would the seller take for all in a 'sold before Auction'
I reckon Roy Stewart knows a wealthy mystery buyer for the lot

stunet's picture
stunet's picture
stunet Monday, 13 Oct 2014 at 11:59am

Also, there's an FB group that I'm a part of, Vintage Surfboard Collectors. Someone linked the auction page to the group and there's been some great discussion about it, specifically about the boards in the collection that have been restored. Original, unrestored boards being the most sought after and valuable.

Some of the crew in the group are incredible, their knowledge of surfboards and history far beyond anyone I've met, and to make it even better they're not afraid to venture their opinions. It's a funny little corner of the surfing world that I didn't realise existed till recently.

There's one board in the collection, a Bobby Brown shaped G&S, one of only a few in existence, that's been restored and the restorer has put their name on the board. So not only is it an unoriginal board - having been restored - but it also has a strangers name sharing the credit along with Bobby Brown. 

Did he do it out of ego? Is it a bad misjudgement? Ahhh, the opinions are flying...

udo's picture
udo's picture
udo Monday, 13 Oct 2014 at 12:05pm

Horlo that Curren board should be in this auction.

Rabbits68's picture
Rabbits68's picture
Rabbits68 Monday, 13 Oct 2014 at 12:08pm

The collection sounds amazing.

Bummer about another apartment development at pristine Smiths Beach though..........

Blowin's picture
Blowin's picture
Blowin Monday, 13 Oct 2014 at 2:16pm

How much for the lot ? Any guesstimates ?

stunet's picture
stunet's picture
stunet Monday, 13 Oct 2014 at 2:24pm

Conservatively I reckon he'll get somewhere north of $200,000.

indo-dreaming's picture
indo-dreaming's picture
indo-dreaming Monday, 13 Oct 2014 at 3:43pm

Wooh that collection is crazy, its a crying shame its getting split, hope to god some of these find homes where the public can enjoy them.

I think if i had a choice id take the MP board, then the MR boards.

gavin007's picture
gavin007's picture
gavin007 Monday, 13 Oct 2014 at 5:02pm

161 cars and 56 bicycles for a 100 seat restaurant???? That's complete Bull !!!

fitzroy-21's picture
fitzroy-21's picture
fitzroy-21 Tuesday, 14 Oct 2014 at 10:26am

Agreed. I would have taken them to task on that one and fought it.

earthbound's picture
earthbound's picture
earthbound Tuesday, 14 Oct 2014 at 1:37pm

wonder how big the whole proposal was and whether it really is in keeping with the local area's character?

gavin007's picture
gavin007's picture
gavin007 Tuesday, 14 Oct 2014 at 8:54pm

Hi Earthbound. A very good point. I haven't been to Smiths Beach to have a first hand opinion on this so I viewed at it via Google Earth. Smiths has one hell of a large resort, but that's about it. The rest seems coastal bush and farmland. I guess it would depend on the design, how it integrates with the rest of the place and, as you put it, whether it is keeping with the local area's character.

However, the council insisting that the car park be made larger and accepting the rezoning seems to contradict this. I don't know, the whole council attitude seems absurd.

undiesundies's picture
undiesundies's picture
undiesundies Wednesday, 15 Oct 2014 at 2:30pm

Hi Gavin 007, check my post below, Richard's proposal was not on the coast but another rural property between Yalls and Dunsborough. Also it was not just a restaurant & museum he was after!

gavin007's picture
gavin007's picture
gavin007 Wednesday, 15 Oct 2014 at 9:20pm

Thanks undiessundies! I hadn't seen your comment before. Things are falling into place and it looked like it were to be a very large development.

mikehunt207's picture
mikehunt207's picture
mikehunt207 Tuesday, 14 Oct 2014 at 9:59am

@Stunet, I picked up an early model single fin with orange "Bobby Brown" logo on deck from garage sale years ago and have been wondering where it came from. Nothing written on it .

earthbound's picture
earthbound's picture
earthbound Tuesday, 14 Oct 2014 at 1:35pm
mikehunt207 wrote:

@Stunet, I picked up an early model single fin with orange "Bobby Brown" logo on deck from garage sale years ago and have been wondering where it came from. Nothing written on it .

Post some images please!!

the-u-turn's picture
the-u-turn's picture
the-u-turn Tuesday, 14 Oct 2014 at 11:26am

It is indeed a heck of a collection, and one can only feel for Richard he has put in the yards for many, many years to aquire this group of boards. A pity the WA Govt and local council lacked the foresight required. There are though some fascinating collections in Australia, some in locale's you would and would not expect. The real motherlode, by a considerable margin, belongs to one of the real gents of our culture on the Goldie. The day the doors of the warehouse are swung open will be an occasion itself....rows, and rows, and further rows of treasure.

the-roller's picture
the-roller's picture
the-roller Tuesday, 14 Oct 2014 at 11:33am

Restoring and oldie might make the thing look nice, but in everything else collectable and or historical. restoring and or refinishing is a complete no-no!

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/roadshow/tips/woodfinish.html

freeride76's picture
freeride76's picture
freeride76 Tuesday, 14 Oct 2014 at 12:01pm

Yep, wandering through Carl's collection is insane.

Slight bit of cognitive dissonance about the profits from this ending in a resort at Smiths.

earthbound's picture
earthbound's picture
earthbound Tuesday, 14 Oct 2014 at 1:34pm

It always interests me when someone blames Council for not being able to do something which is so good for the community at large. From my experience as a building designer and builder, most Councils define requirements like carparks by simple formulas to avoid conflict, and a good designer should know these details in advance of designing. Furthermore, if that is the true amount involved then it indicates a massive project, which may not be in keeping with the Smiths Beach area? Perhaps My Hadley isn't elaborating fully on his true project's depth? I understood the Smiths Beach area is under focus for the resident's attempts to reduce development...not sure that another apartment block is going to be in keeping with the area's flavour either...perhaps Mr Hadley doesn't really have the local community in mind at all?

Another aspect that interests me is the fact that most of these comments have been about how much of a big loss it is to the surfing community that these boards aren't going to be shown...whilst that is a loss in part, I can't help but feel a bigger loss for the small collector who is being taken out of the equation by these big spenders who are able to outbid the average punter, to own a board which inherently is just an investment for them, as shown by the fact that Richard is only concerned with how to best deal with the sale of his items, rather than the personal attachment he has to any of them? Maybe I'm cynical, but I'm seeing so many of these boards being hung on walls of well-to-do halls now, rather than in the hands of those who really treasure them. If Richard were truly on the pulse of the scene, he'd be aware that online bidding would enable everyone to have a shot at this enviable bevy of boards...rather than being available only to those who've got the coin to go to WA in person, pay for the airfare to get there and transport them back. Good fortune to the local WA collectors!!!

maxe's picture
maxe's picture
maxe Tuesday, 14 Oct 2014 at 4:31pm

Over regulation gone completely mad, welcome to Australia, Id say this earthbound guy probably works at the said Council BTW!

I am more than willing to swap you a couple of vintage Mitchell Garcia reels for one of your nice boards.

zenagain's picture
zenagain's picture
zenagain Tuesday, 14 Oct 2014 at 5:16pm

Earthbound, don't you think after nearly 30 years of investing his time and money, he's not reasonably entitled to get the highest rate of return for his efforts?

I don't think it was an easy decision for him to let them go but in the words of an old hippy 'Comes a time'.

Good luck to him I reckon and I hope their new owners cherish them as you alluded to.

udo's picture
udo's picture
udo Tuesday, 14 Oct 2014 at 6:00pm

Richard Hadley : real estate agent, auctioneer, is this the same guy ?

udo's picture
udo's picture
udo Tuesday, 14 Oct 2014 at 9:03pm

Gav007, the West Australian regional april 29th 2014 explains a little more on the approval/non approval ??

undiesundies's picture
undiesundies's picture
undiesundies Wednesday, 15 Oct 2014 at 1:17pm

Thought I'd clarify a couple of things with Richard Hadley's proposal. The site where he wanted the development was not at Smiths Beach but a rural property halfway between Yallingup and Dunsborough. It was not just a surf museum, it included a caravan park, 10 chalets, brewery, tavern, restaurant, arts & crafts studio & reception centre. So the museum was only a small component of the bigger picture! The Council did grant development approval, despite some things should have required rezoning however their conditions of approval were onerous according to Mr Hadley. Without looking into the proposal I assume the 161 parking bays were all inclusive of the tourist development but I too would of questioned the need for them all to be sealed?! I's a real shame the collection did not end up on display for the world to see and that the local authority & Mr Hadley didn't come to some mutual agreement, a bit of give & take, for this to happen. It would have rivalled anything over east or in the states.

gsm1973's picture
gsm1973's picture
gsm1973 Thursday, 16 Oct 2014 at 10:37am

Does any one have Richard's contact details?

udo's picture
udo's picture
udo Thursday, 16 Oct 2014 at 12:34pm

.

reecen's picture
reecen's picture
reecen Wednesday, 22 Oct 2014 at 2:10am

MP stole the show.

stunet's picture
stunet's picture
stunet Wednesday, 22 Oct 2014 at 7:07am

What did it go for Reece? I heard the prices of some of the earlier pieces and they were exceeding expectations, some by a fair margin.

reecen's picture
reecen's picture
reecen Wednesday, 22 Oct 2014 at 9:13am

The MP went for 14k the MR for 10k.
I think the owner and auctioneer would have been smiling, most boards attracted healthy bidding.

stunet's picture
stunet's picture
stunet Wednesday, 22 Oct 2014 at 9:50am

Wot? $14,000! Unbelievable. There was a bit of conjecture before the auction that it may bomb: freight costs limited overseas buyers, as did the bidding process (no online or over-the-phone bidding), but I guess people underestimated how much money there is floating around.

reecen's picture
reecen's picture
reecen Wednesday, 22 Oct 2014 at 10:45am

There was a few boards sold over the phone and the phone bids certainly had a bit of cash behind them.
Keep inind as well that the 14k board attracted another 15% buyers premium and 1.5% GST.

stunet's picture
stunet's picture
stunet Wednesday, 22 Oct 2014 at 1:39pm

Here are the prices for last night's auction. Safe to say the bids were way above what was expected, few people wondering what's in the water over WA way. Certainly there were no bargains to be had. Thanks to Andrew Dykstra. Check the closing prices against the items here.

1,$2100 
2,$1700
3,$4200
4,$3100
5,$5200
6,$2300
7,$2200
8,$1700,
9,$1600
10,$2200
11,$2300
12,$1000
13,$1100
14,$1800
15,$1450
16,$850
17,$ 1700 
18,$850
19,$3100
20,$4800
21,$1000
22,$2100
23,$4000
24,$2600
25,$3000
26,$2300
27,$1600
28,$9000
29,$1800
30,$600
31,$2300
32,$1750
33,$1500
34,$2200
35,$1050
36,$3100
37,$3900
38,$7000
39,$5000
40,$3000
41,$4400
42,$2500
43,$3000
44,$ 3100
45,$1900
46,$1550
47,$1800
48,$950
49,$2750
50,$1650
51,$ 1250
52,$4500
53,$3100
54,$1700
55,$1800
56,$5000
57,$2300
58,$2200
59,$3800
60,$950
61,$1000
62,$1500
63,$850
64,$900
65,$1450
66,$2500
67,$1550
68,$2600
69,$1650
70,$1150
71,$1000
72,$2900
73,$3000
74,$1400
75,$3400
76,$3000
77,$1000
78,$14000
79,$1900
80,$10000
81,$3600
82,$3400
83,$2300
84,$1500
85,$1600
86,$1800
87,$3500
88,$1500
89,$1800
90 $1000
91,$950,
92,$2900
93,$4000
94,$1200
95,$1000
96,$2100
97 $1000
98 $4100
99 $1800
100 $2000
101 $1900
102 $1300
103 $3100
104 $2000
105 $2000
106 $3000
107 $5500
108 $2100
109 $6400
110 $2000
111 $1500

stunet's picture
stunet's picture
stunet Wednesday, 22 Oct 2014 at 1:49pm

And in case you're wondering that all adds up to $281,050!