Russell Ord and the light-fingered Facebook fiends
There was an argument on the internet this morning. Oh yeah, just one of a thousand stoushes going down on the online frontier. But looking past the moral outrage and blazing indignation this little melee had some relevancy, especially for the photographers amongst us.
A Facebook page called World Wide Waves was the latest in a slew of pages stealing surf photographers work and reproducing them uncredited. The photos are used to attract people and increase their likes. World Wide Waves, however, raised the stakes by banning the photographers questioning the practice. One of them was West Oz photographer, the always outspoken, Russell Ord.
Swellnet: Where do sites like World Wide Waves get the photos from? Russell Ord: I wouldn't have a clue. They could be from heaps of places, I wouldn't know exactly as they don't credit where they come from or who took them.
You've been pretty upfront in demanding these Facebook pages give due credit? What I started doing was crediting my own shots. Just making comments. That's enough for them to start firing away which is ridiculous, I mean, they take all the time to write these messages back to me and they can't put 'Photo Russell Ord' at the start?
And it wasn't even my shot that set them off this time. I just wrote, 'Who took that?' I thought it might have been Spence's [Spencer Hornby] shot from Ours. And they replied, 'We don't effing do this and we don't do that.'
So the shot they banned you over wasn't even yours? Nah, but I'm banned from the whole site now. Sometimes you get blown away by other people's work and I wanted to know who took it. So I asked who took the shot and boom!
A couple of weeks ago I credited my own shot on their page so they're obviously getting a bit nancy about it now.
You've been fighting the good fight for a while now, have you managed to convince any pages to start crediting photos? Yeah, there's a couple, I can't recall what their names were, one of them sent me a real long private message and said he's trying to change the way they think about it in the office. Cos there's a group of them involved. And then all of a sudden everyone was getting credited on that site. It only takes half a second to write it, and if you share it you don't need to do anything, it's credited straight back. But when you take the photos from somewhere else, you know, you should just credit the photographer or at least the source.
Why do you think they're not crediting? I don't know.
Do you think they're from outside the industry and don't understand the protocol? Well, it could be, for sure. They've obviously never taken a photo in their life cos they don't appreciate it. And they're heaps of these sites! They ride off the back of the surf industry and take everyone's stuff. I've been fighting this for years, I'm used to copping it, but these guys [World Wide Waves] are definetely giving it to me this time.
Is there anything that can be done? Have you approached Facebook? Facebook have already got a share function which is fine, I don't know why they don't use it. I'm trying to look on Facebook but I'm not getting any response. It's difficult. Ultimately I don't think Facebook give a shit.
Where to from here? What else can you do? Ha...I could probably harden up cos they're giving it to me. I don't know, I'll just say my little piece and it'll blow over in a day or two just like anything...
But it'll pop up again... Yeah, it'll pop up again.
You mentioned you've been talking to other photographers, is there a united front between photogs to deal with this? Every now and again we all get on our high horse and we put messages on someone's site, someone whose been using uncredited work. But they just ban you. And then you can't do anything, but they can still take your photos. It's kind of amazing, there's got to be a way around it. I should have a chat to a lawyer and see if I can send a copyright infringement but I don't like my chances.
Last words...? I'd just love to take 'em out in the water and drown 'em...ha ha ha. They'd probably drown in three foot waves. Honestly. They probably don't even surf but they're taking all our surf shots. And all of this happened because I wanted to know who took the shot. It was a good one.
Postscript: As of half an hour ago World Wide Wave began to credit photos. One was credited to 'A Camera', another to 'J.A.Ckass.' Clearly humour ain't a strong suit.
Comments
Erick Regnard, one half of the Tungsten photo duo, has some good info in this thread:
https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10151640164639134&set=a.43429410...
Ive noticed Ive been ripped off too... grrrrr
I would just like to say that this trend is becoming extremely common, sure a number of facebook pages seem to be negligent however tumblr is even worse. There's so many surf photos on that site which are seen by thousands of people. It's really dissapointing from the surf photographers perspective especially when many of the photos aren't given credit and some receive up to 500,000 views.
Couldn't they just credit the Photog's and buy likes, like so many other sites do ?
Nothing like death threats to bring things to a head. On the weekend the administrator of the Facebook page World Wide Wave, the page in question above, posted this message:
"Ok here it goes , My name is Chris . I started this page not even a year ago just for fun . I included 7 other people as administrators . I though it would give things variety . The whole purpose of this page was to Include the photographers in on the Surf Stoke we all love. Unfortunatley , I recieved a phone call threating my life because of some photos . So with the info I was given I immediatley checked out WWW . I dont get to visit my own page to often . I was under the assumption everyone was having fun , Gues again huh ? Anyway I would like to apologize to all for those that were offended . I have since removed everyone from this page as administrators except my personal friend who actually love's this page and certainly gives everyone there much deserved due . I cant say sorry enough . I hate that this happened ! I hope that I will get some positive feed back on what everyone thinks this page should be about ."
He also posted this message about Russell Ord: "This Guy is a Class act ... I think this Sunday should be Russell Ord day here at the wave . No doubt ! I will most diffenitly be Shareing your photos Mr. Ord . Thank you sir !"
And now it's all peace and love on the internets.
At least it just photos, i had a Indonesian surf travel website a while back, other week I discovered that the main camp/resort at Lakey peak stole all my content and used it for one of there many sites for there place.
I don't really care too much as ive taken the website offline quite a while ago, but still they must have ripped off all the content/info while it was still online, cheeky bastards!
One of those Surfing Atlas of Australia publications ripped off three of my photos from the pin up board at the local trading post. They must of had a portable scanner. I couldn't believe it when I opened up the guide and saw my pictures there. I had the last laugh though as one of the shots I actually took at Kirra and put up on the wall for a laugh. The guy was wearing boardshorts in the shot which should have been a dead giveaway. Not very often you can wear boardies down here!