Coastal Creationism - Part 7: Coral reefs are even better than you think!
How coral reefs help create surf perfection
Coral reefs are exciting for surfers and not only due to the waves they help shape. Of course, they only occur in tropical parts of the planet so they come bundled with the full package of tropical joy. For example, either the winds are light due to the equatorial doldrums, or they're consistent trade winds. One way or another it means that wherever coral reefs grow the atmospheric conditions are conducive to great surf.
Surfing photographers, magazines, and filmmakers all love coral reef waves as, not only is the wind often good, but the water is invariably clear and blue. This is not an accident - reef-forming hard corals will only grow in warm clear waters. Thankfully tropical seas have a way of keeping it just so. The hot tropical sun warms the surface waters and they become less dense than cooler deeper waters, developing a strong thermocline. This layering of the water column is due to decreasing temperatures and increasing density with depth. Cool waters are usually denser and richer in nutrients, so the warm surface layer actually blocks nutrients from entering the sunlit surface waters. This means that not only is the water boardshorts warm, but the lack of nutrients minimises algal growth, keeping the water clear and ideal for coral reef growth.
Surprisingly the lack of nutrients is no limitation to abundance and diversity of life forms. Coral reefs have unlocked the key to an extraordinary bloom of life, based on cooperation and recycling in spite of the limitation of nutrients. The utopian world of the coral reef holds many examples and concepts that could easily cross from ecology to economy. For example a sustainable steady-state of diversity and productivity is based on harvesting energy and resource flows, with little or no waste or loss. Energy and nutrients are not ‘consumed’ then thrown away as waste. Rather energy and nutrients are incredibly valuable and what's leftover by one organism becomes the nourishing basis for the next life form - and so on.
The coral reef ecosystem is also self-equalising, constantly adapting to changing conditions so as to optimise function. For example, islands are constantly subsiding as their weight depresses the oceanic crust. As a result the water gets deeper and the coral grows up toward the light, building the reef to the perfect depth. Extend this process over a few million years and a fringing reef becomes a barrier reef. Then the island sinks below the waves entirely, leaving an atoll.
The atoll may persist for a geologically long time however it is the pace of change in sea level rather than the overall change in depth that eventually overwhelms the atoll. For example, when an island subsides, or sea level rises faster than the reef can grow upwards, it sinks below the surface to become a flat topped sea-mount called a ‘guyot’. Even millions of years after the island has formed, grown reefs, subsided, and then disappeared below the waves, they still remain highly productive fisheries hidden below the surface.
Corals are best known for the stunning and intricate structures of limestone (aragonite) they secrete when forming a home for the colony. But the living organism is a small colonial animal with tentacles, a stomach and a mouth that also doubles up as an anus when required!
Amazingly, these tiny coral polyps don't just filter feed, they do a little symbiosis on the side. The cooperation - that is, the symbiotic relationship - occurs between coral polyp animals and primitive photosynthesising zooxanthellae, a microscopic organism that is not plant but not really animal either, they are a type of photosynthesising bacteria. The coral build a home in a zone of optimum sunlight and clean water. The coral also generates proteins helpful to their microscopic tenants. The zooxanthellae pay the rent by using sunlight to photosynthesise (like plants) and create carbohydrate (food) from sunlight, water, and carbon dioxide. The bright colours of a healthy reef are actually the colours of the zooxanthellae. Giant clams have also locked onto this winning strategy, hosting brightly coloured zooxanthellae in the lips of the clam.
With the work of photosynthesising taken away from those slimy green algae, the coral reef food chain requires a different basis. The coral polyps and the limited things that grow on the coral exoskeleton provide this basis, but it is magnified by opportunity. Thankfully not only do corals create food and biomass, they also create incredibly diverse yet attractive habitats. From deep, dark, and low wave energy reef walls to bright shallow lagoons and back reefs, there are incredible opportunities for organisms to find a niche that suits them.
In the second point of recycling, you can consider a coral reef as a large and dynamic city, and each process generates some wastes. Thankfully the recycling team are so effective that the very limited nutrients are kept cycling through the ecosystem with little or no loss. The result is an ecosystem of staggering diversity, abundant biomass, and strong flows of energy and nutrients throughout. If you have ever snorkelled on a healthy reef you have probably seen an example of this in action, with parrotfish grazing, biting off small chunks of coral and algae, then pooing out the limestone creating a pile of sand. Bigger fish will eat the parrot fish and shrimp will feed around the poo/sand pile. These then are part of the food chain and the nutrient cycle.
The end result of this virtuous cycle is a long-lived, resilient, adaptable living structure. The best thing for surfers is these coral reefs are extremely effective at building broad reefs with slightly convex profiles and curved plan shapes oriented at ideal peel angles amongst a low wind or predictable trade wind climate. And they do it in warm, gin-clear tropical waters, usually in developing countries that are both stunning and exceptionally good value for the travelling surfer.
What’s not to like?
In next week's article we look more closely at the process affecting reef growth and structure and how this can be applied to understanding good waves.
Coastal Creationsim is an eight part series written by Chris Buykx. Chris is a geologist, traveller and lifelong surfer. Specialising in eco-tourism, his passion is interpreting nature and the environment. Chris is a resident of Sydney’s Northern Beaches though he's currently doing a lap of Australia with his family. Read past articles:
Part 1: Basic reef shapes
Part 2: Complex curves
Part 3: The good, the bad, and the ugly of coasts
Part 4: Sedimentary sequences and superior shapes
Part 5: Sand dunes and limestone
Part 6: Slabs!
Comments
Mmmm coral reefs now were talking.
Indo, you might need to do some of the talking about the reefs you are dreaming of. Unfortunately, I have little experience in Indo so I won't be commenting much on specific reefs in Indo - I will leave that to you and our readers. I will only weigh in on reefs I have personally surfed or dived in Pacific and Indian oceans.
This week is the intro to coral reefs - next week gets a bit more specific about the surf zone on reefs
Im no expert but heres a thought and maybe I'm getting a bit ahead of things: As we know coral reefs are live living things more easily shaped by nature than say hard rock like granite, obviously you get reefs passes where water runs off and cuts through and shape the reefs in this way often from a river/creek where fresh water kills coral, but i guess even from lagoons and areas where water needs to exit from tide or swell action.
But i guess wave action also helps shape coral reefs in how they grow, for instance as we know Indonesia has arguably the largest collection of high quality coral reefs in the world.
Is it possible that this is in part due to the fact it gets consistent long period ground swell that grooms and shapes the reefs into a more even shape?…and that an area where there is coral reefs that gets hit with consistent long period swell is more likely to have high quality reefs formed than coral reefs that are in areas that receive inconsistent swell or more low period swells.
Because it kind of seems this way.
That said obviously good coral reefs can form anywhere and there is other influences like coastline shape, geography, offshore water depths and shape etc
Chris amazing article , can you tell us what the ningaloo is doing wrong ? Why 270 km of reefs doesn't provide many surfbreaks . Has this topic been covered already
Thats a good question, because it gets good swell like Indo, i guess winds and tides play a part in how a reef shapes up…doesn't it get strong seasonal winds up there and big tidal differences?
Indo, you are definitely on to something there. I expand on it a little with next weeks story. However your point that consistent long period ground swell helps shape reefs is very significant. Research has shown that wave energy is one of the most important drivers of reef morphology - and long period ground swell is our favourite form of wave energy.
Caml's question relates to the other driver of reef growth sunlight (or lack of it). Next week talks about in detail but we know that fresh water from rivers can create reef passes. This is because nutrients encourage algal growth, when combined with turbidity restrict sunlight, therefore restrict reef growth - bingo - you get a pass forming in the reef.
Caml would know that the Ningaloo coast is extremely arid - and it has been for a very long time. This is why Ningaloo reef grows as a fringing reef right on the continental coast, rather than on the other side in the wet tropics the Great Barrier Reef is way offshore, removed from the turbidity and nutrients of the rivers.
The extension of this is - find the creeks and rivers and that is where you will find the reef passes (on an arid coast creeks are very few). This is where you might just find a wave - I will leave the rest to your deductive abilities.
The well known breaks of the Ningaloo coast are all bends in the reef unrelated to reef passes. The are either reefs growing on fossil reefs forming a good shape (Red Bluff and Exmouth reefs) or bends in the reef (Gnarloo).
My observations for reefs on the GBR and Pacific islands are there are certain types of stunted hard corals that grow in the surf zone as no doubt they are the only ones that can handle the semi-regular pounding it cops from swell. Toatally different from the ones that see little or no swell. Plus there has to be an original rock base for it to start the foundations and formations on.
In the places I've been in Indo, I've found a little different in the corals in the surf zones whilst still being of quite a hard stunted coral.
As a side note, I'm led to believe there is some quite amazing diving away from the populated surf areas of Indo.
Looking forward to the next installment of this series.
Explained so simply Chris I had thought it was a lot more complex . Have dived bluff & gnarlu left breaks Checked the section across tombys !
I had a snorkel around the tombies reef while I was there. There is some nasty looking chunks of coral waiting for some unsuspecting punter to get folded over. Heaps of sharks too!
Having spent a lot of time around the GBR QLD I have noticed mmany of the outer reefs facing the Se trade swell are really steep to,almost like a cliff on the exposed sides.But some of the Rfs down Swains way exposed to more long period swell do seem to have better slope for surfing also in closer around Cap Bunkers have that better shape for surfing.Rfs up north generally just don't seem to be able to cause the swell to refract,justs hits the hard edge and surges over.(spent many frustrated years looking)tho I'm sure there's exeptions...
The GBR is interesting as it gets two very different swells - the SE trade winds and the NE-E cyclones. Both can be energetic but never long period, which would restrict the depth that the wave energy feels the reef. The Southern and Eastern reefs like Swains and Lady Elliot be exposed to the odd groundswell.
Coral reefs are insane. It amazes me how on the side of an island which is open to the ocean swell has its barrier reef protecting it while around the other side where it doesn't need protection from the sea you generally get insane sandy beaches